1. Home

Garden City apartments for rent - Indianapolis, IN

Beds

85 Apartments

Average Rent in Indianapolis, IN

Avg. RentAnnual Change
Indianapolis Studio - $1,295+9%
Indianapolis 1 Bed - $1,205+4%
Indianapolis 2 Beds - $1,398+3%

Search by Property Type

Local Guide

See what Indianapolis, IN has to offer.

Local Reviews

There are many middle class families that live around. Schools do not have busses so kids walk or bike to school. It is nice to see improvements being made to homes in the area.

The uniqueness is being safe. Kroger and so many other stores on the line I would like to stay home and have a deep chat with family and friends.

I loveeee the skating ring in my neighborhood I also love the people really nice I love the bond it's like we're all the same in the neighborhood

Demographics

Education

High School

59%

Associate's

26%

Bachelor's

11%

Master's

2%

Doctorate

1%

Family Size

2 people

38%

3 people

21%

4 people

25%

5 people

8%

6+ people

8%

Household Income

0-50k

70%

50-100k

27%

100-150k

3%

150-200k

0%

200k+

1%

Age

0-10

21%

10-20

13%

20-45

37%

45-65

22%

65+

7%

Affordability

Percentage: 4/54/5

Renters gave this area a 4 out of 5 for affordability

*The rent information included in this summary is based on a median calculation of multifamily rental property inventory on Apartment Guide and Rent.com over the past 12-months and is for illustrative purposes only. This information does not constitute a pricing guarantee or financial advice related to the rental market.

Rent Trends

Average rent in Garden City, Indianapolis, IN

In Indianapolis, IN, as of 2024, the average rent for apartments ranges from $1,205 to $1,398. Specifically, the average rent for a studio apartment in Garden City, Indianapolis, IN is $1,295. For those seeking a 1-bedroom apartments, the average rent is $1,205. And for a 2-bedroom apartment, renters can expect to pay an average of $1,398.

Annual Rent Change Over the Past 12 Months

Studio

+9%

Changed from $1,188 to $1,295
1 Bed

+4%

Changed from $1,159 to $1,205
2 Beds

+3%

Changed from $1,357 to $1,398

Cost of Living

Compared to State Average

1.3%

Compared to National Average

7.3%

The cost of living in Garden City, Indianapolis, IN is 1.3% lower than the state average and 7.3% lower than the national average. Garden City, Indianapolis, IN housing is 20.9% less expensive than the U.S average, while utilities are about 0.2% less pricey. When it comes to basic necessities such as food and clothing, groceries are around 0.2% less in Garden City, Indianapolis, IN than in the rest of the country.

Healthcare services such as doctor check-ups and dentistry cost 10.9% less here compared to the U.S. average.
Cost of Living in Garden City, Indianapolis, INCompared to State AverageCompared to National Average
Housing
0.3%
20.9%
Utilities
2.8%
0.2%
Food
1.1%
0.2%
Transportation
0.2%
4.4%
Healthcare
5.4%
10.9%

Compare Other Cities

CityStudio Avg RentAnnual Change
Fishers$1,305+8%
Indianapolis$1,295+9%
Carmel$1,292+15%
Bloomington$1,232+6%
Whitestown$1,163--
Brownsburg$1,160-6%
Noblesville$1,097-1%
Crawfordsville$1,095+39%
Westfield$1,073-20%
Greenwood$963-16%
Lebanon$850--
City1 Bed Avg RentAnnual Change
Whitestown$1,730-4%
Carmel$1,610+4%
Westfield$1,494+4%
Zionsville$1,462+4%
Noblesville$1,363+3%
Brownsburg$1,265-16%
Avon$1,265-4%
Bloomington$1,242+5%
Indianapolis$1,205+4%
Fishers$1,195-25%
Columbus$1,172-8%
Camby$1,125+91%
Greenwood$1,122-11%
Greenfield$1,059-6%
Beech Grove$1,052+5%
Lebanon$975+17%
Franklin$960+19%
Plainfield$870+4%
Anderson$783+6%
Crawfordsville$600-20%
City2 Beds Avg RentAnnual Change
Carmel$2,038+8%
Westfield$1,767+6%
Whitestown$1,765-5%
Zionsville$1,663-11%
Camby$1,625+132%
Avon$1,547-1%
Bloomington$1,430+7%
Fishers$1,405-32%
Indianapolis$1,398+3%
Brownsburg$1,388-27%
Greenwood$1,363-13%
Noblesville$1,340-8%
Columbus$1,330+1%
Greenfield$1,232-4%
Plainfield$1,210+5%
Franklin$1,160+23%
Beech Grove$1,159+1%
Crawfordsville$1,095+10%
Lebanon$1,089+10%
Anderson$949+11%

Compare Neighborhoods

Chapel Hill - Ben Davis

$574

1 Bed Avg. Rent

Martindale - Brightwood

$675

1 Bed Avg. Rent

North Perry

$705

1 Bed Avg. Rent

What are the most affordable neighborhoods in Indianapolis, IN?

For renters in Indianapolis seeking more affordable options, the neighborhoods to watch are Chapel Hill - Ben Davis, Martindale - Brightwood, and North Perry, where average rents for 1-bedroom apartments stand at $574, $675, and $705 respectively. Additional areas offering value are Crown Hill and Irvington, where the rents are $725 and $729, a favorable comparison to Indianapolis's overall 1-bedroom average of $1,205.

What are the most expensive neighborhoods in Indianapolis, IN?

In Indianapolis, the neighborhoods commanding the highest rents are Meridian Kessler, Broad Ripple Village, and Fountain Square. A 1-bedroom apartment in Meridian Kessler averages at $2,020, in Broad Ripple Village it averages $1,749, and in Fountain Square, the average is $1,658. For additional high-end living options, Fletcher Place offers 1-bedroom apartments at $1,615, and Near Northside at $1,456. These rates compare to the overall average rent of $1,205 for a 1-bedroom apartment in Indianapolis, highlighting the premium nature of these specific neighborhoods.

What are the most popular neighborhoods in Indianapolis, IN?

In Indianapolis, the most sought-after neighborhoods for renters include Fall Creek Place, Near Northside, and Martindale - Brightwood. In Fall Creek Place, the average rent for a 1-bedroom apartment is $1,350. Near Northside sees average rents of $1,456 for a 1-bedroom unit. Martindale - Brightwood offers similar appeal with 1-bedroom apartments averaging $675. For those seeking other popular areas, Mapleton - Fall Creek presents 1-bedroom apartments at $1,285, and Near Eastside at $997. These prices are set against the backdrop of the city-wide average of $1,205 for a 1-bedroom apartment in Indianapolis, underscoring the popularity of these particular neighborhoods.

NeighborhoodStudio Avg RentAnnual Change
Mass Ave$1,702+40%
West Side$1,589+45%
Chapel Hill - Ben Davis$1,559+21%
North Meridian$1,450-7%
Meridian Kessler$1,444--
Broad Ripple Village$1,424-11%
Downtown Indianapolis$1,372+10%
Fletcher Place$1,3400%
Fountain Square$1,332+28%
I65-South Emerson$1,300--
Fall Creek Place$1,250--
North Side$1,230+7%
Mass Avenue$1,200-1%
College Park$1,125-33%
Mapleton - Fall Creek$1,095-8%
South Perry$967+5%
Valley Mills$927+2%
North High School$900--
St. Vincent - Greenbriar$876+18%
Eagledale$853+119%
Near Northside$840+16%
Near Eastside$838--
Christian Park$838--
East Side$825+10%
Far East Side$825+14%
South Broad Ripple$799-6%
Chatham Arch$7650%
Crooked Creek$764-11%
East Gate$750--
South Side$719-35%
Old Northside$699-26%
Irvington$675--
Near Westside$650+31%
North Perry$6290%
Crown Hill$550-8%
Neighborhood1 Bed Avg RentAnnual Change
Broad Ripple Village$1,749-13%
Fountain Square$1,658+9%
Fletcher Place$1,615-4%
Near Northside$1,456+4%
Downtown Indianapolis$1,454-7%
North Side$1,440+4%
North Meridian$1,350+2%
Fall Creek Place$1,350--
Indiana Avenue$1,300-19%
South Perry$1,294+44%
Mapleton - Fall Creek$1,285-1%
Mass Ave$1,280-12%
College Park$1,275+69%
Southern Dunes$1,268--
Chatham Arch$1,1750%
Valley Mills$1,146+15%
St. Vincent - Greenbriar$1,119+2%
Nora$1,108+6%
South Side$1,094+3%
Five Points$1,051+13%
Crooked Creek$1,049+36%
Near Westside$1,029+96%
Mass Avenue$1,025-35%
South Broad Ripple$1,019+4%
West Side$1,008+10%
Near Eastside$997+11%
Devington$975+12%
East Gate$954+12%
Mars Hill$949--
Far East Side$945+11%
East Warren$9250%
East Side$889+5%
North High School$872-34%
I65-South Emerson$849-1%
Christian Park$804--
Eagledale$765-9%
Old Northside$764-36%
Irvington$729+8%
Near Southeast$729--
Crown Hill$725+4%
North Perry$705-1%
Martindale - Brightwood$675-54%
Chapel Hill - Ben Davis$574-22%
Neighborhood2 Beds Avg RentAnnual Change
Meridian Kessler$2,234--
Fountain Square$1,990+1%
Near Northside$1,850+5%
Fall Creek Place$1,850--
Downtown Indianapolis$1,805-5%
North Meridian$1,715+7%
North Side$1,623-2%
Mapleton - Fall Creek$1,535-2%
Southern Dunes$1,517--
College Park$1,452-6%
St. Vincent - Greenbriar$1,451+11%
Mass Ave$1,430-21%
North High School$1,351-21%
Indiana Avenue$1,350+6%
Nora$1,324+16%
West Side$1,284+5%
South Side$1,282+3%
Five Points$1,258+14%
Valley Mills$1,250+6%
South Perry$1,209+9%
Mass Avenue$1,208-43%
East Warren$1,175+6%
South Broad Ripple$1,159+10%
Near Westside$1,149+35%
Chatham Arch$1,1400%
East Side$1,134+8%
East Gate$1,119+10%
Far East Side$1,109+11%
Crooked Creek$1,054+14%
Mars Hill$1,030+13%
Eagledale$1,018-2%
I65-South Emerson$999+4%
Old Northside$929-42%
North Perry$925+13%
Near Eastside$899+20%
Near Southeast$879+14%
Irvington$849+8%
Crown Hill$849+2%
Devington$700-27%
Chapel Hill - Ben Davis$627-26%

Transportation

Commute Time

0-15 Mins

19%

15-30 Mins

58%

30-40 Mins

15%

40-60 Mins

5%

60+ Mins

3%

Transportation Scores

Percentage: 4141

Walk Score®

Has Sidewalks

Yes

Say 3 of 3 renters

Percentage: 4848

Bike Score®

Bike Friendly

No

Say 2 of 3 renters

Percentage: 3030

Transit Score®

They Are Located Near Public Transportation

No

Say 2 of 3 renters

Area Amenities

Top Score

Grocery Stores

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Not bad on the supermarket score. Garden City Indianapolis gets an average rating.

  1. Few grocery stores per resident
  2. 83% more grocery stores than average
  3. 60% more grocery stores than areas of a similar size

Restaurants

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

An average foodie scene: not too cold and not too hot.

  1. Few restaurants per resident
  2. 54% more restaurants than average
  3. 10% fewer restaurants than areas of a similar size

Parks

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

There's fresh air to be had here.

  1. Few parks per resident
  2. 80% more parks than average
  3. 33% more parks than areas of a similar size

Medical Care

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Healthcare in Garden City Indianapolis doesn't tip the scales.

  1. Few medical facilities per resident
  2. 79% more medical facilities than average
  3. 34% more medical facilities than areas of a similar size

Coffee

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

The coffee scene is lukewarm in Garden City Indianapolis.

  1. Few coffee shops per resident
  2. An average number of coffee shops
  3. A standard number of coffee shops compared to areas of a similar size

Nightlife

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

You'll need to stock up the mini-bar. Garden City Indianapolis is running dry.

  1. Few bars and clubs per resident
  2. 31% more bars and clubs than average
  3. 100% fewer bars and clubs than areas of a similar size

Childcare

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Garden City Indianapolis is low on childcare options so get on the waiting list early.

  1. Few daycares per resident
  2. 60% more daycares than average
  3. 33% fewer daycares than areas of a similar size

Retail Shops

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

The retail inventory is low in Garden City Indianapolis.

  1. Few shops per resident
  2. An average number of shops
  3. A standard number of shops compared to areas of a similar size

Health and Fitness

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

You'll have to workout somewhere else to keep fit.

  1. Few gyms per resident
  2. An average number of gyms
  3. A standard number of gyms compared to areas of a similar size

Pet Services

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Garden City Indianapolis could do with more oppawtunities for pets.

  1. Few pet facilities per resident
  2. An average number of pet facilities
  3. Far fewer pet facilities than areas of a similar size

Theaters

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Hiding in the dressing room? Garden City Indianapolis has a quiet theater scene.

  1. Few theaters per resident
  2. An average number of theaters
  3. A standard number of theaters compared to areas of a similar size

Fine Arts

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

You gotta Van Gogh somewhere else for art.

  1. Few fine art centers per resident
  2. An average number of fine art centers
  3. A standard number of fine art centers compared to areas of a similar size

Amusement Parks

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

In need of a lift: Garden City Indianapolis is light on amusement parks.

  1. Few amusement parks per resident
  2. An average number of amusement parks
  3. A standard number of amusement parks compared to areas of a similar size

Hospitals

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Be patient when looking for a hospital around here.

  1. Few hospitals per resident
  2. An average number of hospitals
  3. A standard number of hospitals compared to areas of a similar size

Gas Stations

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Honk if you see a gas station.

  1. Few gas stations per resident
  2. An average number of gas stations
  3. A standard number of gas stations compared to areas of a similar size

Area Features

Busy Streets

No

Say 3 of 3 renters

Area Has Kids Play Outside

Yes

Say 3 of 3 renters

Noise Late At Night

No

Say 3 of 3 renters

Area Has Litter

No

Say 3 of 3 renters

Near Schools

Yes

Say 3 of 3 renters

Area Has Potholes

No

Say 3 of 3 renters

Good Place To Raise A Family

Yes

Say 3 of 3 renters

Safe For Families

Yes

Say 3 of 3 renters

Mostly Older Buildings

No

Say 2 of 3 renters

Near Grocery Stores

Yes

Say 2 of 3 renters

Quiet Area

Yes

Say 2 of 3 renters

Mostly Newer Buildings

No

Say 2 of 3 renters

Near Highways

No

Say 2 of 3 renters

Nearby Parks

No

Say 2 of 3 renters

Tree Lined Streets

No

Say 2 of 3 renters

Well Lit

No

Say 2 of 3 renters

Maintained Yards

No

Say 2 of 3 renters

Near Downtown

No

Say 3 of 3 renters

Nice Views

No

Say 3 of 3 renters

Pet Friendly

No

Say 3 of 3 renters

Schools

Percentage: 5/55/5

School Score

How satisfied do renters feel with the schools in this area.

Top Schools in Garden City Indianapolis

Information provided by GreatSchools. To verify school enrollment eligibility, contact the school district directly.

Find Apartments in Nearby Cities

City1 Bed Price2 Beds Price
Indianapolis, IN 5 miles$1,205$1,398
Brooklyn, IN 17 miles------
Greenwood, IN 13.2 miles$1,122$1,363
Speedway, IN 2.5 miles------
Carmel, IN 16.2 miles$1,610$2,038
Fishers, IN 18.1 miles$1,195$1,405
Plainfield, IN 9 miles$870$1,210
Brownsburg, IN 9.3 miles$1,265$1,388
Avon, IN 7.8 miles$1,265$1,547
Beech Grove, IN 9.2 miles$1,052$1,159

Find Apartments in Nearby Neighborhoods

Neighborhood1 Bed Price2 Beds Price
West Side 0.7 miles$1,008$1,284
Farley 1.9 miles------