1. Home

Old Northside houses for rent - Indianapolis, IN

6 Properties

  • 1332 N College Ave Photo 1
    1332 N College Ave Photo 2
    $1,700

    1332 N College Ave

    1332 N College Ave unit A, Indianapolis, IN 46202

    2 Beds • 1 Bath

    Available Now

    2 Beds, 1 Bath

    $1,700

    1,167 Sqft

    1 Floor Plan

    Neighborhood

    Old Northside

    Indianapolis House for Rent

    Completely Furnished AirBnb Rental located within short distance to downtown, Indy. Tastefully decorated with everything you need to start over. This is a condo-sytle building. The entrance is towards the back. You will have access to a 1 car garage. If you need additional parking, your guests can park on College Ave. To schedule a tour, call 317-600-9123. To apply, click www.honestpm.com

    House for RentView All Details
    (317) 600-9123
  • 2157 N Park Ave Photo 1
    2157 N Park Ave Photo 2
    $3,000

    2157 N Park Ave

    2157 N Park Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202

    3 Beds • 2 Bath

    Available Now

    3 Beds, 2 Baths

    $3,000

    1,865 Sqft

    1 Floor Plan

    Neighborhood

    Near Northside

    Indianapolis House for Rent

    Welcome to your new home at 2157 N Park Ave! This beautiful and spacious 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom house offers a perfect blend of modern amenities and classic charm. Nestled in a vibrant neighborhood, this property is ideal for families, professionals, or anyone looking for a comfortable and convenient place to call home. Features: Large Living Spaces: Enjoy the open concept living and dining area, perfect for entertaining guests or spending quality time with family. Updated Kitchen: Equipped with stainless steel appliances, ample cabinet space, and a breakfast bar for casual dining. Master Suite: The spacious master bedroom includes an en-suite bathroom with a double vanity, walk-in shower, and generous closet space. Additional Bedrooms: Two additional bedrooms provide plenty of room for family, guests, or a home office. Outdoor Space: A fenced backyard offers a private oasis for outdoor activities and relaxation. Parking: Convenient off-street & Garage parking is available. Nearby Amenities: Cultural Attractions: Just a short drive away, you can explore the Indianapolis Museum of Art and the Children's Museum of Indianapolis, offering enriching experiences for all ages. Parks and Recreation: Enjoy outdoor activities at the nearby Fall Creek Place Park and Martin Luther King Jr. Park, which offer playgrounds, walking trails, and green spaces. Dining and Shopping: The property is conveniently located near the bustling Mass Ave district, known for its eclectic mix of restaurants, cafes, boutiques, and entertainment venues. Healthcare: Close proximity to IU Health Methodist Hospital and other healthcare facilities ensures peace of mind for you and your family. Education: The property is within reach of quality schools and educational institutions, making it an excellent choice for families. Transportation: Accessibility: Easy access to major highways (I-65 and I-70) ensures quick commutes to downtown Indianapolis and other parts of the city. Public Transit: The property is well-served by public transportation, with several bus routes nearby. This home offers a perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and community. Don't miss the opportunity to make 2157 N Park Ave your new address. Contact us today to schedule a viewing and experience all that this fantastic property has to offer! Contact Information: Please submit the form on this page or contact us at (773) 816-9891 to learn more. This property is managed by a responsible landlord using Avail Landlord software.

    House for RentView All Details
    (773) 816-9891
  • 814 N Park Ave Photo 1
    814 N Park Ave Photo 2
    $2,450

    814 N Park Ave

    814 N Park Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202

    2 Beds • 2 Bath

    Available Now

    2 Beds, 2 Baths

    $2,450

    1,200 Sqft

    1 Floor Plan

    Top Amenities

    • Washer & Dryer In Unit
    • Air Conditioning
    • Dishwasher
    • Hardwood Flooring

    Neighborhood

    Chatham Arch

    Indianapolis House for Rent

    Property Id: 1466726 Located just a 3 minute walk from Bottleworks and Mass ave, you'll find your charming, newly renovated home nestled in Historic Chatham Arch, Downtowns most desirable neighborhood. Designed for those with distinguishing taste; The property features a front yard, 2 bedrooms each with their own bathrooms, soaring open ceilings of up to 15 feet, lots of natural light, a gas fireplace, hardwood floors, genuine marble and oak finishes, for a warm natural, midcentury vibe. As well as brand new bathrooms and a brand new kitchen with high-end stainless steel appliances including an exterior vented stove. For those who need it, you will find lots of space for storage as well as a private parking space behind the house. Property Id 1466726 Apply at TurboTenant: http://rental.turbotenant.com/p/814-n-park-ave-indianapolis-in/1466726

    House for RentView All Details
    (704) 807-8729
  • 2246 Alabama St Photo 1
    2246 Alabama St Photo 2
    $2,100

    2246 Alabama St

    2246 Alabama St, Indianapolis, IN 46205

    3 Beds • 2 Bath

    Available Now

    3 Beds, 2 Baths

    $2,100

    1,050 Sqft

    1 Floor Plan

    Top Amenities

    • Washer & Dryer In Unit
    • Dishwasher
    • Hardwood Flooring

    Neighborhood

    Fall Creek Place

    Indianapolis House for Rent

    FALL CREEK PLACE // Welcome to this beautiful 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home! This house offers granite counter tops, stainless steel appliances, a granite double vanity in one full bath, hardwoods and tile throughout main living spaces! Fenced in backyard with parking! Walking distances to local restaurants and pubs!

    House for RentView All Details
    (317) 513-4251

Average Rent in Indianapolis, IN

Avg. RentAnnual Change
Indianapolis Studio - $1,169-2%
Indianapolis 1 Bed - $1,221+4%
Indianapolis 2 Beds - $1,409+5%
Last updated 5/27/2024

Search by Property Type

Local Guide

See what Indianapolis, IN has to offer.

Local Reviews

I'm straight I cannot think of any possible things about my neighborhood It used to be a pretty good neighborhood but now I just full of drugs and crime

It is close to the college campus. It is close to the most popular street here, with local shops and restaurants.

Alot of really nice homes. It is great for raising children. It is close to a large populated downtown.s.

It is unique because it is very near downtown but feels residential. I like that they maintain a small community space and do an annual cleanup.

I love how close to downtown it is. Also there's a lot of restaurants close by. There's so much to do that is near me

Close to downtown beautiful views public transportation emergency staff close by. People can walk they're pets ride their bicycles and jog.

Demographics

Education

High School

19%

Associate's

29%

Bachelor's

32%

Master's

17%

Doctorate

3%

Family Size

2 people

68%

3 people

17%

4 people

8%

5 people

6%

6+ people

1%

Household Income

0-50k

53%

50-100k

21%

100-150k

14%

150-200k

5%

200k+

8%

Age

0-10

5%

10-20

3%

20-45

61%

45-65

22%

65+

8%

Affordability

Percentage: 3/53/5

Renters gave this area a 3 out of 5 for affordability

Last updated 5/27/2024

*The rent information included in this summary is based on a median calculation of multifamily rental property inventory on Apartment Guide and Rent.com over the past 12-months and is for illustrative purposes only. This information does not constitute a pricing guarantee or financial advice related to the rental market.

Rent Trends

Average rent in Old Northside, Indianapolis, IN

In Indianapolis, IN, as of 2024, the average rent for apartments ranges from $1,169 to $1,409. Specifically, the average rent for a studio apartment in Old Northside, Indianapolis, IN is $1,169. For those seeking a 1-bedroom apartments, the average rent is $1,221. And for a 2-bedroom apartment, renters can expect to pay an average of $1,409.

Annual Rent Change Over the Past 12 Months

Studio

-2%

Changed from $1,193 to $1,169
1 Bed

+4%

Changed from $1,174 to $1,221
2 Beds

+5%

Changed from $1,342 to $1,409
Last updated 5/27/2024

Cost of Living

Compared to State Average

1%

Compared to National Average

6.3%

The cost of living in Old Northside, Indianapolis, IN is 1% lower than the state average and 6.3% lower than the national average. Old Northside, Indianapolis, IN housing is 20.1% less expensive than the U.S average, while utilities are about 3.2% more pricey. When it comes to basic necessities such as food and clothing, groceries are around 0.1% more in Old Northside, Indianapolis, IN than in the rest of the country.

Healthcare services such as doctor check-ups and dentistry cost 10.8% less here compared to the U.S. average.
Cost of Living in Old Northside, Indianapolis, INCompared to State AverageCompared to National Average
Housing
2.1%
20.1%
Utilities
3.3%
3.2%
Food
1.4%
0.1%
Transportation
0.4%
3.9%
Healthcare
5.6%
10.8%

Compare Other Cities

CityStudio Avg RentAnnual Change
Fishers$1,305+8%
Carmel$1,235+12%
Bloomington$1,229+6%
Indianapolis$1,169-2%
Brownsburg$1,160-6%
Noblesville$1,097-1%
Crawfordsville$1,095+39%
Westfield$1,085-1%
Greenwood$926-19%
Lebanon$850--
Mooresville$775--
Columbus$730+5%
Kokomo$715+8%
Muncie$5950%
Anderson$4620%
City1 Bed Avg RentAnnual Change
Carmel$1,615+4%
Westfield$1,506+6%
Zionsville$1,462-3%
Noblesville$1,349+2%
Avon$1,280-2%
Bloomington$1,252+6%
Brownsburg$1,235-18%
Indianapolis$1,221+4%
Columbus$1,201+1%
Fishers$1,180-25%
Greenwood$1,132-9%
Greenfield$1,059-6%
Lebanon$975+17%
Martinsville$929+13%
Kokomo$890+11%
New Castle$871+5%
Mooresville$870--
Shelbyville$8110%
Anderson$779+5%
Muncie$695+3%
Crawfordsville$600-20%
Frankfort$600--
City2 Beds Avg RentAnnual Change
Carmel$2,034+6%
Westfield$1,794+6%
Zionsville$1,735-7%
Avon$1,566-2%
Bloomington$1,500+12%
Brownsburg$1,434-20%
Fishers$1,427-31%
Indianapolis$1,409+5%
Noblesville$1,381-3%
Columbus$1,375+6%
Greenwood$1,357-13%
Greenfield$1,215-6%
Frankfort$1,200--
Crawfordsville$1,095+10%
Lebanon$1,089+10%
Martinsville$1,075+10%
Kokomo$1,022+11%
Mooresville$980--
Shelbyville$966+1%
Anderson$962+12%
New Castle$934+6%
Muncie$895+12%

Compare Neighborhoods

Chapel Hill - Ben Davis

$574

1 Bed Avg. Rent

Herron - Morton Place

$649

1 Bed Avg. Rent

Martindale - Brightwood

$675

1 Bed Avg. Rent

What are the most affordable neighborhoods in Indianapolis, IN?

For renters in Indianapolis seeking more affordable options, the neighborhoods to watch are Chapel Hill - Ben Davis, Herron - Morton Place, and Martindale - Brightwood, where average rents for 1-bedroom apartments stand at $574, $649, and $675 respectively. Additional areas offering value are Near Southeast and Irvington, where the rents are $729 and $729, a favorable comparison to Indianapolis's overall 1-bedroom average of $1,221.

What are the most expensive neighborhoods in Indianapolis, IN?

In Indianapolis, the neighborhoods commanding the highest rents are Meridian Kessler, Broad Ripple Village, and Fountain Square. A 1-bedroom apartment in Meridian Kessler averages at $2,020, in Broad Ripple Village it averages $1,749, and in Fountain Square, the average is $1,633. For additional high-end living options, Fletcher Place offers 1-bedroom apartments at $1,565, and I65-South Emerson at $1,500. These rates compare to the overall average rent of $1,221 for a 1-bedroom apartment in Indianapolis, highlighting the premium nature of these specific neighborhoods.

What are the most popular neighborhoods in Indianapolis, IN?

In Indianapolis, the most sought-after neighborhoods for renters include Near Eastside, Near Northside, and Martindale - Brightwood. In Near Eastside, the average rent for a 1-bedroom apartment is $997. Near Northside sees average rents of $1,407 for a 1-bedroom unit. Martindale - Brightwood offers similar appeal with 1-bedroom apartments averaging $675. For those seeking other popular areas, Grace Tuxedo Park presents 1-bedroom apartments at $909, and Irvington at $729. These prices are set against the backdrop of the city-wide average of $1,221 for a 1-bedroom apartment in Indianapolis, underscoring the popularity of these particular neighborhoods.

NeighborhoodStudio Avg RentAnnual Change
Meridian Kessler$1,444--
Fletcher Place$1,440+7%
Broad Ripple Village$1,399-10%
Downtown Indianapolis$1,365+10%
Fountain Square$1,306+26%
I65-South Emerson$1,300--
South Franklin$1,300--
Garden City$1,287-2%
West Side$1,264+10%
Chapel Hill - Ben Davis$1,259-13%
Near Northside$1,229+70%
Mass Avenue$1,200-1%
North Side$1,149+3%
Mapleton - Fall Creek$1,095-8%
South Perry$967+5%
South Side$935-17%
Valley Mills$927--
Near Eastside$838--
East Side$825+10%
Far East Side$825+16%
South Broad Ripple$799-6%
Irvington$675--
Garfield Park$675--
Near Westside$650+31%
Neighborhood1 Bed Avg RentAnnual Change
Broad Ripple Village$1,749-5%
Fountain Square$1,633+8%
Fletcher Place$1,565-5%
I65-South Emerson$1,500+63%
Downtown Indianapolis$1,462-7%
Near Northside$1,407+52%
North Side$1,404+2%
South Franklin$1,340+13%
Southern Dunes$1,290--
Mapleton - Fall Creek$1,282-2%
South Perry$1,253+30%
Mass Avenue$1,225-21%
Glenn's Valley$1,190-5%
Valley Mills$1,146--
South Side$1,112+6%
Five Points$1,051+13%
Allisonville$1,024+15%
West Side$1,008+5%
Garden City$1,001+3%
Near Eastside$997--
Near Westside$979+98%
Devington$975+12%
Mars Hill$949+19%
Far East Side$945+10%
East Warren$925+6%
Grace Tuxedo Park$909+29%
East Side$908+4%
South Broad Ripple$894-11%
Christian Park$804--
Near Southeast$729--
Irvington$729+8%
Martindale - Brightwood$675-54%
Herron - Morton Place$649--
Chapel Hill - Ben Davis$574-22%
Neighborhood2 Beds Avg RentAnnual Change
Fountain Square$2,135+12%
Downtown Indianapolis$1,867+1%
Near Northside$1,850+80%
South Franklin$1,707+19%
North Side$1,588-4%
Mapleton - Fall Creek$1,532-7%
Glenn's Valley$1,472+12%
Southern Dunes$1,457--
Allisonville$1,414+13%
Broad Ripple Village$1,361-1%
Herron - Morton Place$1,349--
Garden City$1,335+7%
South Side$1,300+5%
West Side$1,284+7%
Five Points$1,258+14%
Garfield Park$1,250--
Valley Mills$1,244--
South Perry$1,209+7%
Mass Avenue$1,208-43%
East Warren$1,202+9%
East Side$1,132+7%
Near Westside$1,112--
Far East Side$1,096+10%
Mars Hill$1,086+19%
South Broad Ripple$1,049-9%
I65-South Emerson$999-15%
Near Eastside$899+20%
Near Southeast$879+26%
Grace Tuxedo Park$872-5%
Irvington$849+8%
Devington$700-27%
Chapel Hill - Ben Davis$627-26%

Transportation

Commute Time

0-15 Mins

40%

15-30 Mins

39%

30-40 Mins

13%

40-60 Mins

5%

60+ Mins

3%

Transportation Scores

Percentage: 7474

Walk Score®

Walkable

Yes

Say 4 of 6 renters

Has Sidewalks

Yes

Say 4 of 6 renters

Percentage: 7575

Bike Score®

Bike Friendly

Yes

Say 3 of 6 renters

Percentage: 5252

Transit Score®

They Are Located Near Public Transportation

Yes

Say 4 of 6 renters

Need A Car

Yes

Say 3 of 6 renters

Area Amenities

Top Score

Nightlife

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Nightlife is on the rocks in Old Northside Indianapolis.

  1. A high number of bars and clubs per resident
  2. 86% more bars and clubs than average
  3. 83% more bars and clubs than areas of a similar size

Fine Arts

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

It's just about fine for fine art. An average score.

  1. A high number of fine art centers per resident
  2. 94% more fine art centers than average
  3. 91% more fine art centers than areas of a similar size

Grocery Stores

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

The food shops around here are few and far between.

  1. Few grocery stores per resident
  2. An average number of grocery stores
  3. A standard number of grocery stores compared to areas of a similar size

Restaurants

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Old Northside Indianapolis serves up a dining scene that's only lukewarm.

  1. Few restaurants per resident
  2. An average number of restaurants
  3. A standard number of restaurants compared to areas of a similar size

Coffee

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

The coffee scene is lukewarm in Old Northside Indianapolis.

  1. Few coffee shops per resident
  2. An average number of coffee shops
  3. A standard number of coffee shops compared to areas of a similar size

Parks

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Not too many park perks in Old Northside Indianapolis.

  1. Few parks per resident
  2. An average number of parks
  3. A standard number of parks compared to areas of a similar size

Childcare

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Old Northside Indianapolis is low on childcare options so get on the waiting list early.

  1. Few daycares per resident
  2. An average number of daycares
  3. A standard number of daycares compared to areas of a similar size

Retail Shops

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

The retail inventory is low in Old Northside Indianapolis.

  1. Few shops per resident
  2. An average number of shops
  3. A standard number of shops compared to areas of a similar size

Health and Fitness

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

You'll have to workout somewhere else to keep fit.

  1. Few gyms per resident
  2. An average number of gyms
  3. A standard number of gyms compared to areas of a similar size

Pet Services

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Old Northside Indianapolis could do with more oppawtunities for pets.

  1. Few pet facilities per resident
  2. An average number of pet facilities
  3. A standard number of pet facilities compared to areas of a similar size

Theaters

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Hiding in the dressing room? Old Northside Indianapolis has a quiet theater scene.

  1. Few theaters per resident
  2. An average number of theaters
  3. A standard number of theaters compared to areas of a similar size

Medical Care

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

We have a bone to pick with this Old Northside Indianapolis's access to medical care.

  1. Few medical facilities per resident
  2. 26% fewer medical facilities than average
  3. A standard number of medical facilities compared to areas of a similar size

Gas Stations

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Honk if you see a gas station.

  1. Few gas stations per resident
  2. An average number of gas stations
  3. A standard number of gas stations compared to areas of a similar size

Area Features

Near Downtown

Yes

Say 6 of 6 renters

Noise Late At Night

No

Say 5 of 6 renters

Area Has Litter

No

Say 5 of 6 renters

Well Lit

Yes

Say 5 of 6 renters

Busy Streets

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Mostly Older Buildings

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Near Grocery Stores

Yes

Say 4 of 6 renters

Pet Friendly

Yes

Say 4 of 6 renters

Good Place To Raise A Family

Yes

Say 4 of 6 renters

Tree Lined Streets

Yes

Say 4 of 6 renters

Near Highways

Yes

Say 3 of 6 renters

Nearby Parks

Yes

Say 3 of 6 renters

Area Has Potholes

Yes

Say 3 of 6 renters

Area Has Kids Play Outside

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Mostly Newer Buildings

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Near Schools

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Quiet Area

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Safe For Families

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Maintained Yards

No

Say 4 of 6 renters

Nice Views

No

Say 5 of 6 renters

Schools

Percentage: 3/53/5

School Score

How satisfied do renters feel with the schools in this area.

Top Schools in Old Northside Indianapolis

Information provided by GreatSchools. To verify school enrollment eligibility, contact the school district directly.

Find Houses in Nearby Cities

City1 Bed Price2 Beds Price
Indianapolis, IN 1.3 miles$1,221$1,409
Fishers, IN 13.8 miles$1,180$1,427
Avon, IN 13.4 miles$1,280$1,566
Brownsburg, IN 13.8 miles$1,235$1,434
Greenfield, IN 20.2 miles$1,059$1,215
Greenwood, IN 12.1 miles$1,132$1,357
Beech Grove, IN 5.4 miles$1,052$1,159
Zionsville, IN 12.9 miles$1,462$1,735
Carmel, IN 13.4 miles$1,615$2,034
Mooresville, IN 16.9 miles$870$980

Find Houses in Nearby Neighborhoods

Neighborhood1 Bed Price2 Beds Price
Downtown Indianapolis 1.2 miles$1,462$1,867
Near Northside 0.9 miles$1,407$1,850
Mass Avenue 0.7 miles$1,225$1,208
Chatham Arch 0.5 miles$1,175$1,140
Herron - Morton Place 0.5 miles$649$1,349
Cottage Home 0.8 miles------
Fletcher Place 1.9 miles$1,565$2,190
Fall Creek Place 1.1 miles$1,350$1,850
Lockerbie Square 1 miles------
Windsor Park 1 miles------