Otterbein, Indianapolis, IN

Otterbein Neighborhood Guide Indianapolis, IN

About

Otterbein is a charming neighborhood located in Indianapolis, Indiana. Featuring a variety of homes, from cozy bungalows to modern apartments, it's a vibrant and diverse community. Residents appreciate the accessibility provided by its proximity to Interstate 70 and the convenience of being minutes away from downtown Indianapolis. Nearby sporting venues, such as the Lucas Oil Stadium, and cultural offerings like the Indiana State Museum and the Eiteljorg Museum add to the appeal of the area.

What You Will Love About Otterbein, Indianapolis, Indiana

  • Residents enjoy Otterbein's blend of urban living with a community feel, providing a comfortable setting for both families and young professionals.
  • The neighborhood is celebrated for its accessibility to downtown Indianapolis, making it easy to commute or enjoy the city's dining, shopping, and entertainment options.
  • Sports enthusiasts will love being near Lucas Oil Stadium, home to the Indianapolis Colts.

What’s Nearby

Otterbein is close to major Indianapolis attractions like the Eiteljorg Museum, the Indiana State Museum, and the NCAA Hall of Champions. It's also just a short drive away from the vibrant downtown area, which offers plenty of restaurants, shops, and nightlife venues.

Lifestyle

The lifestyle in Otterbein is ideal for those who appreciate city living with the warm sense of a close-knit community. Residents enjoy easy access to Indianapolis's cultural, sports, and entertainment offerings, while also being able to retreat to a peaceful and friendly neighborhood.

Notice an Inaccuracy? Let Us Know.

See best properties in this area

Explore the Neighborhood

There are 31 restaurants, 13 grocery stores, and 11 parks within a mile of the Otterbein neighborhood.

  • GROCERY
    Indianapolis Fruit Company

    Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Fruit and Vegetable Store, Grocery Store

    0.7 miles

    4501 Massachusetts Ave

  • GROCERY
    Safeway Foods

    Retail, Drugstore, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store

    0.8 miles

    2435 N Sherman Dr

  • GROCERY
    Kline's Quality Water

    Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Coffee Roaster, Grocery Store

    1.0 mile

    2250 N Ritter Ave

  • GROCERY
    Green Bean Delivery

    Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store

    1.0 mile

    5310 E 25th St

  • GROCERY
    Kroger Pharmacy

    Retail, Drugstore, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store

    1.1 miles

    4445 E 10th St

  • GROCERY
    Kroger

    Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store

    1.1 miles

    4445 E 10th St

Otterbein Apartments and Rentals

126 Rental properties in Otterbein, Indianapolis, IN.

  • Gladstone Apartments property

    $771+

    Gladstone Apartments

    Studio–1 Beds • 1 Bath

    449–658 Sqft

    10+ Units Available

  • Linwood Manor property

    $543+

    Linwood Manor

    1 Bed • 1 Bath

    850 Sqft

    10+ Units Available

  • 938 Jefferson Ave property

    $1,750

    938 Jefferson Ave

    3 Beds • 1 Bath

    1500 Sqft

    1 Unit Available

  • 2021 N Drexel Ave property

    $1,199

    2021 N Drexel Ave

    3 Beds • 1 Bath

    1680 Sqft

    Available 7/1

  • 1015 N Sheridan Ave property

    $1,150

    1015 N Sheridan Ave

    2 Beds • 1 Bath

    864 Sqft

    Available Now

  • 1833 N Hawthorne Ln property

    $1,070

    1833 N Hawthorne Ln

    2 Beds • 1 Bath

    873 Sqft

    Available Now

Cost of Living

basic bar chart art
CategoryCompare to State Avg.Compare to National Avg.
housing
0.3%
20.9%
utilities
2.8%
0.2%
food
1.1%
0.2%
transportation
0.2%
4.4%
healthcare
5.4%
10.9%

Otterbein Demographics

people in their homes

Otterbein Reviews

people smiling
  • Noise Late At Night

    No

    Say 7 of 7 renters

  • Busy Streets

    No

    Say 6 of 7 renters

  • Area Has Litter

    No

    Say 6 of 7 renters

  • Area Has Kids Play Outside

    Yes

    Say 5 of 7 renters

  • Mostly Older Buildings

    No

    Say 5 of 7 renters

  • Near Grocery Stores

    Yes

    Say 4 of 7 renters

Otterbein Schools

Neighborhoods Around Otterbein

NeighborhoodStudioAvg RentAnnual Change
Near EastsideNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$838--
East SideNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$825
10%
Fountain SquareNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$1,306
26%
Mass AvenueNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$1,200
1%
IrvingtonNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$675--
Mass AveNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$1,651
36%
Downtown IndianapolisNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$1,365
10%
Martindale - BrightwoodNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
Old NorthsideNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$699
27%
Near NorthsideNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$1,229
70%
Chatham ArchNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$765
0%
Brookside ParkNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
Grace Tuxedo ParkNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
Fletcher PlaceNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$1,440
7%
Mapleton - Fall CreekNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$1,095
8%
Bosart BrownNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
Christian ParkNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
Crown HillNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$550
8%
HillsideNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
DevingtonNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
MeadowsNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
South Broad RippleNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$799
6%
Fall Creek PlaceNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$1,250--
North MeridianNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$1,450
3%
Indiana AvenueNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
Near SoutheastNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
East GateNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$750--
Meridian KesslerNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$1,444--
Bates - HendricksNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
Wholesale DistrictNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----
FairgroundsNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$939
20%
MillersvilleNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana$841
4%
Raymond ParkNeighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana----