Living Room - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Dining Room - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Kitchen - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Kitchen - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Living Room - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Bedroom - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Bedroom - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Bathroom - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Kitchen - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Dining Room - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Living Room - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Bathroom - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Living Room - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Playground - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Community Signage - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Building - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
Building - Mid Island Apartments - Bay Shore, NY
$1,860+

Mid Island Apartments

Islip
  • Studio–2 Beds
  • 1–1.5 Baths
  • 400-875 Sqft
Managed by Eagle Rock Management
Mid Island Apartments

Contact Property

Learn more, take a tour, and get one step closer to your new home.

(516) 744-1621

or

Request Tour

Let the property know when you're available, and they will contact you to arrange a tour.

You're requesting anytime on 5/26.

New Lower Price: 2 floor plans recently dropped their price. Prices change weekly. Contact Today!

Popular RentalPopular Rental Direction

555 people recently viewed this rental

Top Features

  • Air Conditioning
  • Dishwasher
  • Washer & Dryer Connections
  • Laundry Facility
  • Hardwood Flooring

Floor Plans

3 Units Available
Studio
  • Price Drop
    S1
    $1,860+
    $1,860 - $2,822/mo
    Studio, 1 Ba400 Sqft
    400 Sqft
    • 0531D
      $2,095
      Studio, 1 Ba
      400 Sqft
      Jul 23
    • 0732B
      $2,085
      Studio, 1 Ba
      400 Sqft
      Aug 2
    • 0551B
      $2,075
      Studio, 1 Ba
      400 Sqft
      Aug 7
    • 0552E
      $1,860
      Studio, 1 Ba
      400 Sqft
      Oct 1
1 Bedroom
  • Price Drop
    A1
    $1,920+
    $1,920 - $3,344/mo
    1 Bd, 1 Ba665 Sqft
    665 Sqft
    • 0191A
      $2,255
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      665 Sqft
      Today
    • 0291A
      $2,330
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      665 Sqft
      Today
    • 0152D
      $1,920
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      665 Sqft
      Jun 27
    • 0252A
      $2,210
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      665 Sqft
      Jul 29
  • A2
    $1,935+
    $1,935 - $3,427/mo
    1 Bd, 1 Ba705 Sqft
    705 Sqft
    • 0611A
      $2,335
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      705 Sqft
      Today
    • 0612D
      $2,300
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      705 Sqft
      Jun 2
    • 0552A
      $2,235
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      705 Sqft
      Jun 21
    • 0692A
      $2,265
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      705 Sqft
      Jul 2
    • 0531F
      $1,935
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      705 Sqft
      Jul 4
    • 0631F
      $2,340
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      705 Sqft
      Aug 2
    • 0732F
      $2,230
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      705 Sqft
      Aug 2
    • 0691A
      $2,320
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      705 Sqft
      Aug 18
    • 0592D
      $2,270
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      705 Sqft
      Aug 21
    • 0652F
      $2,300
      1 Bd, 1 Ba
      705 Sqft
      Sep 2
2 Bedrooms
  • B3
    $2,685+
    $2,685 - $3,949/mo
    2 Bd, 1 Ba870 Sqft
    870 Sqft
    • 3612C
      $2,685
      2 Bd, 1 Ba
      870 Sqft
      Sep 10
  • B1
    $2,705+
    $2,705 - $3,971/mo
    2 Bd, 1 Ba820 Sqft
    820 Sqft
    • 3612B
      $2,705
      2 Bd, 1 Ba
      820 Sqft
      Sep 29
  • B4
    $2,735+
    $2,735 - $3,970/mo
    2 Bd, 1 Ba1 Half Ba875 Sqft
    875 Sqft
    • 0211C
      $2,735
      2 Bd, 1 Ba
      875 Sqft
      Aug 16
  • B2
    Contact for Price
    Contact for Price
    2 Bd, 1 Ba
    Upcoming Availability
  • B5
    Contact for Price
    Contact for Price
    2 Bd, 1 Ba
    Upcoming Availability

Floor plans are artist's rendering. All dimensions are approximate. Actual product and specifications may vary in dimension or detail. Not all features are available in every rental home. Prices and availability are subject to change. Rent is based on monthly frequency. Additional fees may apply, such as but not limited to package delivery, trash, water, amenities, etc. Deposits vary. Please see a representative for details.

Pet Policy

The ins and outs of having pets

dogs

Dogs Allowed
Maximum two pets per apartment. Monthly fees: $50 per dog. Non-refundable fee: $300 per pet. Breed restrictions and other limitations apply.
Maximum weight
40 lbs.
Initial Fee
$250
Maximum pets
2
Additional rent
$50

cats

Cats Allowed
Maximum weight
20 lbs.
Initial Fee
$200
Maximum pets
2
Additional rent
$25

Amenities & Features

21 Amenities & Features

Living Space

  • Air Conditioning
  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Hardwood Flooring
  • Oversized Closets
  • Washer & Dryer Connections

Perks

  • High Speed Internet Access

Kitchen

  • Dishwasher
  • Garbage Disposal
  • Refrigerator
  • Stainless Steel Appliances

Features

  • Laundry Facility
  • Playground
  • Smoke Free

Management Details

  • Accepts Credit Card Payments
  • Accepts Electronic Payments
  • Emergency Maintenance
  • On Site Maintenance
  • On Site Management
  • Short Term Available

Unique

  • Cable Amenity - $75 Fee
  • Open Lot Parking

Total Cost & Fees

$1,935-$4,046 projected monthly cost

Est. Monthly Costs

$1,935-$4,046

Est. One-Time Fees

$450

Electricity estimates are provided by WattBuy for informational purposes only.

Parking

Options and pricing

Surface Lot

  • Not Assigned Parking
  • No Parking Fee
  • 1 per Unit
  • Parking Available.

About This Property

Learn more about this property
Mid Island Apartments is more than just a place to call home. Our quality studio, one, and two-bedroom apartment homes have been upgraded to match your lifestyle. This quaint community, built with traditional brick architecture, is surrounded by expansive green courtyards and tucked into the historic Bay Shore neighborhood on Long Island, New York. Our recently remodeled, pet-friendly homes feature hardwood flooring, and stainless-steel appliances. Enticing outdoor adventure, delicious dining options, charming coffee shops, and highly rated schools are just minutes from Mid Island Apartments.

Community Information

278 Units

Building Type

Apartments

Managed By

Eagle Rock Management

Schools

Learn about schools near this property
Information provided by GreatSchools . To verify school enrollment eligibility, contact the school district directly.

Transportation Options

35 N Penataquit Ave is: Somewhat Walkable

Somewhat Walkable

65/100
Walk Score®
The Walk Score© measures walkability on a scale of 0-100 based on walking routes to destinations such as dining and drinking, groceries, and shopping.
  • Dining & Drinking
    72
  • Groceries
    68
  • Shopping
    73

Transit

1 train stop, 6 bus stops
    Union Blvd/Penataquit Ave
    Bus Stop • 0.06mi
      Montauk Hwy/Brentwood Rd
      Bus Stop • 0.2mi
        Brook Ave/Mackay Rd
        Bus Stop • 0.4mi

        Somewhat Bikeable

        48/100
        Bike Score®

        Nearby Places

        10 grocery stores, 10 restaurants, 10 parks
        Loading…

        Ratings & Reviews

        Rent. 3.5 (10)See what people are saying

        Review this property

        Share details of your own experience
        5
        3
        4
        2
        3
        3
        2
        1
        1
        1
        • 5/5 stars based on undefined reviews
          February 26, 2024

          the place look to be very nice

          Anonymous
          Was this helpful?0
        • 4/5 stars based on undefined reviews
          July 07, 2021

          Very spacious complex

          Anonymous
          Was this helpful?0
        • 5/5 stars based on undefined reviews
          March 06, 2021

          I just moved here and I really like it and recommend it, its quiet and peaceful. Mark the property manager is a really nice person and hes very helpful and goes out of his way to meet your needs.

          Anonymous
          Was this helpful?0
        • 2/5 stars based on undefined reviews
          November 02, 2020

          2 stars because I never heard back from them so I don't know what it is like. Bad customer service I guess..

          Anonymous
          Was this helpful?1
        • 3/5 stars based on undefined reviews
          July 20, 2020

          So far no one has gotten back to me

          Anonymous
          Was this helpful?1
        • 3/5 stars based on undefined reviews
          July 20, 2020

          I received a response but because I am an independent contractor and do not have paystubs I could not be considered for the apartment

          Anonymous
          Was this helpful?1

        Leasing Terms

        Short or long term? Learn your options

        Term Length

        2-Month, 3-Month, 4-Month, 5-Month, 6-Month, 7-Month, 8-Month, 9-Month, 10-Month, 11-Month, 12-Month, 13-Month, 14-Month, 15-Month, 16-Month, 17-Month, 18-Month, 19-Month, 20-Month, 21-Month, 22-Month, 23-Month, 24-Month

        Details

        Our lease terms are: 2 months, 3 months, 4 months, 5 months, 6 months, 7 months, 8 months, 9 months, 10 months, 11 months, 12 months, 13 months, 14 months, 15 months, 16 months, 17 months, 18 months, 19 months, 20 months, 21 months, 22 months, 23 months, 24 months. (Please note that lease terms may vary, are subject to change without notice, and are based on availability. Inquire with property staff for complete details).

        Office Hours

        Open today until 05:30 PM
        • Sunday

          Closed
        • Monday

          09:00 AM - 05:30 PM
        • Tuesday

          09:00 AM - 05:30 PM
        • Wednesday

          09:00 AM - 05:30 PM
        • Thursday

          09:00 AM - 05:30 PM
        • Friday

          09:00 AM - 05:30 PM
        • Saturday

          09:00 AM - 05:30 PM
        • Contact Us

        35 N Penataquit Ave

        Bay Shore, NY 11706
        Islip

        Similar Properties

        • Fairfield On The Lake property

          $2,155+

          Fairfield On The Lake

          Studio–2 Beds • 1 Bath

          416–1151 Sqft

        • Brookwood at Islip property

          $2,191+

          Brookwood at Islip

          1–2 Beds • 1 Bath

          820–950 Sqft

          2 Units Available

        • Fairfield Renaissance property

          $2,255

          Fairfield Renaissance

          1 Bed • 1 Bath

          675 Sqft

        • Fairfield Tudor At Bay Shore property

          $2,380+

          Fairfield Tudor At Bay Shore

          1–2 Beds • 1–2 Baths

        • Fairfield North At Bay Shore property

          $2,390+

          Fairfield North At Bay Shore

          1–2 Beds • 1 Bath

          700–865 Sqft

        • Fairfield Eastbrook Gardens property

          $2,285+

          Fairfield Eastbrook Gardens

          1–2 Beds • 1 Bath

          782–978 Sqft

          4 Units Available

        • Brookwood at Bay Shore property

          $2,113+

          Brookwood at Bay Shore

          1–2 Beds • 1 Bath

          522–670 Sqft

          1 Unit Available

        • Stone Water Gardens property

          $2,025+

          Stone Water Gardens

          1–2 Beds • 1 Bath

          1 Unit Available

        • Fairfield Arms property

          $2,295+

          Fairfield Arms

          1–2 Beds • 1 Bath

          580–890 Sqft

          3 Units Available

        • Park Haven Place property

          $1,599+

          Park Haven Place

          Studio–2 Beds • 1 Bath

          525–1141 Sqft

        We take fraud seriously. If something looks fishy, let us know. Report This Listing.

        Find Apartments in Nearby Cities

        Find Apartments by Max Price

        Bay Shore Apartments Options

        Popular Cities to Rent in

        Other Properties in New York

        Looking for more?

        Welcome to Mid Island Apartments, an exceptional apartment complex in the historic Bay Shore neighborhood of Long Island, New York. Our recently upgraded studio, one, and two-bedroom homes are designed to suit your modern lifestyle, offering stylish and convenient features. Step inside our pet-friendly apartments and be greeted by gleaming hardwood floors and sleek stainless-steel appliances. Our thoughtfully designed layouts cater to your needs, whether you seek a cozy studio or a spacious two-bedroom. Each home boasts oversized closets and washer & dryer connections for added convenience. At Mid Island Apartments, we go above and beyond to provide you with an exceptional living experience. Enjoy a host of amenities, including air conditioning, ceiling fans, high-speed internet access, and a playground. Our dedicated management and maintenance teams are always available to assist you, ensuring a stress-free and comfortable lifestyle. Discover the vibrant surroundings of Bay Shore, just minutes away from our community. Immerse yourself in outdoor adventures, indulge in delectable dining experiences, savor the charm of local coffee shops, and benefit from highly rated schools. Whether you're a nature lover or a seeker of hidden gems, you'll find something to suit your interests in this dynamic neighborhood. Experience the epitome of Bay Shore living at Mid Island Apartments. Contact us today to schedule a tour and secure one of our newly upgraded apartments as your new home.