1. Home

Middle Island Apartments For Rent

129 Properties

Middle Island Apartment Options

Avg. RentAnnual Change
1 Bed - $2,620+8%
2 Beds - $2,755+9%
3 Beds - $3,338-
Last updated 10/4/2022

Search by Property Type

Overview of Middle Island

Located along the shores of New York about 50 miles outside of New York City, Middle Island, NY is a tight-knit census-designated community located about halfway between eastern and western ends of Long Island. Consisting of about 8.2 square miles, the town holds about 12,300 residents. It is located within the Town of Brookhaven and part of the Longwood Central School District, the largest system on Long Island. People looking for Middle Island apartments for rent will have no trouble finding a lovely space to call home.

Living in Middle Island, NY

Middle Island became a well-known city in 1766 when the first Presbyterian church was built. As an extension of Long Island, the town's rich history was formed by being one of the first suburbs in United States history. Originally settled by the Lenape tribe, Long Island later became a hub for settlers and immigrants from all over the world. Prestigious Wall Street workers moved to Long Island in the 19th century after the ferry system allowed them to commute to and from work.

Today, Long Island is known for its beautiful landscape and friendly culture. Wall Street is one of the region's top employers, with finance being a huge industry for the area. Real estate and banking are also big players, with retail taking a large portion of the region's employment as well.

Middle Island Attractions and Special Events

Middle Island is a ferry ride away from metropolitan New York, as well as a number of its lovely suburban towns. In addition, New York City's two major airports, LaGuardia Airport and John F. Kennedy International Airport, are also located on Long Island in the borough of Queens. 

To find a Middle Island apartment or rental, check out our apartment listings. Rent.com® is happy to help you find your next home.

Find Apartments in Nearby Cities

Find Apartments in Nearby Neighborhoods

Find Apartments Near Local Colleges

Find Apartments by Max Price

Find Apartments in Nearby Zip Codes

Counties Near Middle Island

Find Apartments Around Nearby Public Transit

Looking for more?