1. Home

Montauk, NY Houses For Rent

Beds

164 Properties

Local Guide

See what Montauk, NY has to offer.

Local Reviews

kids playing on the neighborhood playground it's so nice seeing kids enjoying themselves on a nice day

We like going in pandas buffet because of the food many Asian food and it's really a lot of food ther

My neighborhood have weekly community meetings. I like the fact that everyone knows everyone. I love all my neighbors.

To be honest the only reason I moved to where I live is because I lost my house due to some medical problems I lost my job everything so I had to move into an income based apartment until I can get myself sorted.

Demographics

Education

High School

31%

Associate's

29%

Bachelor's

31%

Master's

8%

Doctorate

1%

Family Size

2 people

51%

3 people

26%

4 people

17%

5 people

6%

6+ people

0%

Household Income

0-50k

16%

50-100k

35%

100-150k

22%

150-200k

10%

200k+

16%

Age

0-10

9%

10-20

4%

20-45

22%

45-65

33%

65+

33%

Rent Ranges

Apartment PricesProportion
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%

Compare Other Cities

CityStudio Avg RentAnnual Change
Branford$2,500+36%
Riverhead$2,055+4%
New London$1,825--
Newport$1,500-53%
Guilford$1,350--
Norwich$1,2950%
Narragansett$1,200--
Groton$1,195--
Middletown$1,155--
Willimantic$995+1%
City1 Bed Avg RentAnnual Change
Hampton Bays$2,700--
Riverhead$2,300+3%
Middletown$2,3000%
Newport$2,200+22%
Madison$2,200--
New London$2,040+77%
Branford$1,975+31%
Narragansett$1,850+12%
Groton$1,7500%
Waterford$1,7500%
Guilford$1,750-22%
Mastic$1,700--
Westerly$1,400--
Coventry$1,3950%
Willimantic$1,225+4%
Norwich$1,0870%
North Kingstown$1,0350%
Colchester$8570%
City2 Beds Avg RentAnnual Change
Hampton Bays$3,800-62%
Newport$3,000-5%
Clinton$3,0000%
Riverhead$2,735+2%
Jamestown$2,700-73%
Waterford$2,5950%
Stonington$2,500--
Branford$2,375-2%
Narragansett$2,000-13%
Groton$1,942+13%
Middletown$1,800-8%
Westerly$1,700--
Coventry$1,6500%
Colchester$1,650-3%
New London$1,625+35%
Willimantic$1,475+1%
Norwich$1,422+1%
North Kingstown$1,2500%

Compare Neighborhoods

Transportation

Commute Time

0-15 Mins

36%

15-30 Mins

27%

30-40 Mins

20%

40-60 Mins

12%

60+ Mins

6%

Area Amenities

Top Score

Health and Fitness

3.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Looking good! Montauk scores high for health and fitness.

  1. Few gyms per resident
  2. 100% fewer gyms than average
  3. 100% fewer gyms than areas of a similar size

Parks

3/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Montauk is shrubby, not shabby.

  1. A high number of parks per resident
  2. Significantly more parks than average
  3. Significantly more parks than areas of a similar size

Pet Services

3/5 stars based on undefined reviews

It's pawsible that your pets will fall in love with Montauk.

  1. Few pet facilities per resident
  2. 100% fewer pet facilities than average
  3. 100% fewer pet facilities than areas of a similar size

Restaurants

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

An average foodie scene: not too cold and not too hot.

  1. A high number of restaurants per resident
  2. 6% more restaurants than average
  3. 80% more restaurants than areas of a similar size

Coffee

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Not too cold, not too hot. An average town for coffee.

  1. A high number of coffee shops per resident
  2. 6% more coffee shops than average
  3. 88% more coffee shops than areas of a similar size

Nightlife

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Nightlife is on the rocks in Montauk.

  1. A high number of bars and clubs per resident
  2. 49% more bars and clubs than average
  3. 56% more bars and clubs than areas of a similar size

Retail Shops

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

The shopping scene here is a size medium.

  1. A high number of shops per resident
  2. 52% fewer shops than average
  3. 11% more shops than areas of a similar size

Fine Arts

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

It's just about fine for fine art. An average score.

  1. Few fine art centers per resident
  2. 100% fewer fine art centers than average
  3. 100% fewer fine art centers than areas of a similar size

Grocery Stores

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

The food shops around here are few and far between.

  1. A high number of grocery stores per resident
  2. 47% fewer grocery stores than average
  3. 7% more grocery stores than areas of a similar size

Medical Care

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

We have a bone to pick with this Montauk's access to medical care.

  1. Few medical facilities per resident
  2. 100% fewer medical facilities than average
  3. 100% fewer medical facilities than areas of a similar size

Gas Stations

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Honk if you see a gas station.

  1. A high number of gas stations per resident
  2. 49% fewer gas stations than average
  3. A standard number of gas stations compared to areas of a similar size

Schools

Top Schools in Montauk

Information provided by GreatSchools. To verify school enrollment eligibility, contact the school district directly.

About

Montauk, NY

Montauk Neighborhood Guides

If you're trying to find the best neighborhood that meets your needs, checkout our Montauk neighborhood guides. These guides walk you though what its like to live in these neighborhoods

Find Houses in Nearby Cities

City1 Bed Price2 Beds Price
East Hampton, NY 13 miles------
Groton, CT 22.6 miles$1,750$1,942
New London, CT 23.4 miles$2,040$1,625
Westerly, RI 24.5 miles$1,400$1,700
Waterford, CT 23.2 miles$1,750$2,595
Amagansett, NY 10.8 miles------
Sag Harbor, NY 17.8 miles------
Mystic, CT 22 miles------
Stonington, CT 20.9 miles---$2,500
Greenport, NY 21.6 miles$3,500$3,800

Find Houses in Nearby Neighborhoods

Neighborhood1 Bed Price2 Beds Price
The Hamptons$2,200$2,500