1. Home

Coney Island apartments for rent - New York, NY

Beds

15 Properties

Average Rent in New York, NY

Avg. RentAnnual Change
New York Studio - $4,010-6%
New York 1 Bed - $5,097-5%
New York 2 Beds - $6,992-8%
Last updated 6/22/2024

Local Guide

See what New York, NY has to offer.

Local Reviews

It's small, safe and friendly. Lots of walkers and bikers and dogs! We have a park within the subdivision and access to an over 10 mile biking/walking path.

I like that everything is close. We have restaurants, a target and a grocery store all within a few blocks of where I live. When it's nice outside, I can walk to most of these places and I don't have to drive. I like to go to local donut shop, Munster Donuts, and to Arnie's Dog House.

My neighborhood has plenty of places to go, many restaurants, lots of shopping. People are friendly and help each other out. Great mix of people.

The people are welcoming. I don't want the new train station, but other then that I love it here. Plus the kids love the restaurants are very close. They have a lot of friends to hang out with.

This area has a lot of stores Subway,Dunkin,Burger King restaurants are here I like to go to the movies

The human quality of its inhabitants, respect and sense of belonging. What the ad said was interesting to you

Demographics

Education

High School

46%

Associate's

18%

Bachelor's

21%

Master's

14%

Doctorate

1%

Family Size

2 people

49%

3 people

23%

4 people

16%

5 people

7%

6+ people

5%

Household Income

0-50k

66%

50-100k

21%

100-150k

7%

150-200k

2%

200k+

3%

Age

0-10

11%

10-20

11%

20-45

25%

45-65

24%

65+

29%

Affordability

Percentage: 3/53/5

Renters gave this area a 3 out of 5 for affordability

Last updated 6/22/2024

*The rent information included in this summary is based on a median calculation of multifamily rental property inventory on Apartment Guide and Rent.com over the past 12-months and is for illustrative purposes only. This information does not constitute a pricing guarantee or financial advice related to the rental market.

Rent Trends

Average rent in Coney Island, New York, NY

In New York, NY, as of 2024, the average rent for apartments ranges from $4,010 to $6,992. Specifically, the average rent for a studio apartment in Coney Island, New York, NY is $4,010. For those seeking a 1-bedroom apartments, the average rent is $5,097. And for a 2-bedroom apartment, renters can expect to pay an average of $6,992.

Annual Rent Change Over the Past 12 Months

Studio

-6%

Changed from $4,266 to $4,010
1 Bed

-5%

Changed from $5,365 to $5,097
2 Beds

-8%

Changed from $7,600 to $6,992
Last updated 6/22/2024

Cost of Living

Compared to State Average

2.5%

Compared to National Average

3.4%

The cost of living in Coney Island, New York, NY is 2.5% lower than the state average and 3.4% lower than the national average. Coney Island, New York, NY housing is 6.5% less expensive than the U.S average, while utilities are about 4.6% less pricey. When it comes to basic necessities such as food and clothing, groceries are around 3% less in Coney Island, New York, NY than in the rest of the country.

Healthcare services such as doctor check-ups and dentistry cost 0.5% less here compared to the U.S. average.
Cost of Living in Coney Island, New York, NYCompared to State AverageCompared to National Average
Housing
4.5%
6.5%
Utilities
1.5%
4.6%
Food
1.5%
3%
Transportation
4.7%
2.2%
Healthcare
0.3%
0.5%

Compare Other Cities

CityStudio Avg RentAnnual Change
New York$4,010-6%
Hoboken$3,470+74%
Jersey City$3,449-3%
Long Island City$3,322--
Brooklyn$3,313-10%
Weehawken$3,212-1%
Newark$2,6850%
Maplewood$2,432+10%
Stamford$1,928-4%
Queens$1,800+9%
Montclair$1,650+2%
Bronx$1,517-37%
City1 Bed Avg RentAnnual Change
New York$5,097-5%
Brooklyn$4,456+6%
Long Island City$4,269--
Jersey City$3,792-1%
Weehawken$3,703-5%
Hoboken$3,610+5%
Newark$2,542-5%
Stamford$2,516-2%
Queens$2,400+20%
Maplewood$2,305-7%
Montclair$2,249+5%
Bronx$1,767-31%
City2 Beds Avg RentAnnual Change
New York$6,992-8%
Long Island City$6,503--
Brooklyn$6,169+116%
Weehawken$5,826+2%
Jersey City$4,862-1%
Hoboken$4,469+5%
Stamford$3,300-4%
Maplewood$3,097+6%
Queens$2,800+12%
Montclair$2,575+7%
Newark$2,1000%
Bronx$2,0170%

Compare Neighborhoods

Sunnyside

$1,400

1 Bed Avg. Rent

Lenox Hill

$1,425

1 Bed Avg. Rent

Southeastern Queens

$1,914

1 Bed Avg. Rent

What are the most affordable neighborhoods in New York, NY?

For renters in New York seeking more affordable options, the neighborhoods to watch are Sunnyside, Lenox Hill, and Southeastern Queens, where average rents for 1-bedroom apartments stand at $1,400, $1,425, and $1,914 respectively. Additional areas offering value are Washington Heights and Bay Ridge, where the rents are $2,100 and $2,200, a favorable comparison to New York's overall 1-bedroom average of $5,097.

What are the most expensive neighborhoods in New York, NY?

In New York, the neighborhoods commanding the highest rents are SoHo, NoMad, and West Village. A 1-bedroom apartment in SoHo averages at $9,000, in NoMad it averages $6,277, and in West Village, the average is $5,775. For additional high-end living options, Tribeca offers 1-bedroom apartments at $5,765, and Midtown East at $5,748. These rates compare to the overall average rent of $5,097 for a 1-bedroom apartment in New York, highlighting the premium nature of these specific neighborhoods.

What are the most popular neighborhoods in New York, NY?

In New York, the most sought-after neighborhoods for renters include Kips Bay, Gramercy Park, and NoMad. In Kips Bay, the average rent for a 1-bedroom apartment is $4,945. Gramercy Park sees average rents of $4,550 for a 1-bedroom unit. NoMad offers similar appeal with 1-bedroom apartments averaging $6,277. For those seeking other popular areas, Murray Hill presents 1-bedroom apartments at $5,239, and Midtown Manhattan at $5,066. These prices are set against the backdrop of the city-wide average of $5,097 for a 1-bedroom apartment in New York, underscoring the popularity of these particular neighborhoods.

NeighborhoodStudio Avg RentAnnual Change
West Village$5,375-8%
East Village$5,109-6%
Alphabet City$5,109-6%
Murray Hill$5,049-4%
Chelsea$4,875+16%
NoMad$4,6850%
Morningside Heights$4,585+2%
Downtown Manhattan$4,486-18%
Northern Brooklyn$4,156-2%
Williamsburg$4,156-2%
Midtown Manhattan$4,136-2%
Times Square$4,036-8%
Hell's Kitchen$4,010+4%
Hudson Yards$3,966+2%
Lincoln Square$3,732-10%
SoHo$3,4250%
Upper West Side$3,413-10%
Fort Greene$3,411--
Financial District$3,400-24%
Kips Bay$3,350+46%
Downtown Brooklyn$3,293-9%
Upper Manhattan$3,292-14%
Sutton Place$3,200--
Midtown East$3,050+9%
Gramercy Park$3,000--
Yorkville$2,985+33%
DUMBO$2,950--
Lenox Hill$2,715--
Brooklyn Heights$2,710-33%
Upper East Side$2,550+13%
Harlem$2,500-45%
Park Slope$2,500--
East Harlem$2,500-58%
Tudor City$2,400-4%
Greenwich Village$2,350-47%
Prospect Heights$2,312--
Bushwick$2,289--
Washington Heights$1,995+11%
Northeastern Queens$1,995+3%
Flatbush$1,900--
West Bronx$1,771-40%
Southeastern Queens$1,699+4%
Neighborhood1 Bed Avg RentAnnual Change
NoMad$6,277-7%
West Village$5,775+28%
Tribeca$5,765--
Midtown East$5,748+85%
Chelsea$5,703-21%
Alphabet City$5,690-15%
Downtown Manhattan$5,513-9%
Greenwich Village$5,500+20%
Lincoln Square$5,373-1%
Murray Hill$5,239-18%
Morningside Heights$5,217-4%
Upper West Side$5,140-3%
Sutton Place$5,122--
Midtown Manhattan$5,066-3%
Financial District$5,049-9%
East Village$5,010-25%
Harlem$4,997-8%
Kips Bay$4,945-3%
Upper Manhattan$4,916-8%
Williamsburg$4,900-8%
Hell's Kitchen$4,895-5%
Hudson Yards$4,838+4%
DUMBO$4,775--
Park Slope$4,700--
Northern Brooklyn$4,700+18%
Times Square$4,693+3%
Brooklyn Heights$4,658-1%
Fort Greene$4,595--
Gramercy Park$4,550--
Upper East Side$4,497-21%
Greenpoint$4,435--
Yorkville$4,390-23%
Prospect Heights$4,250-10%
Downtown Brooklyn$4,201-2%
Tudor City$3,575--
Bushwick$3,250+30%
Lower East Side$3,125--
West Bronx$2,599+2%
East Harlem$2,500-37%
Flatbush$2,450--
Northeastern Queens$2,250+11%
Bay Ridge$2,200+38%
Ridgewood$2,200+19%
Washington Heights$2,100-7%
Southeastern Queens$1,914+1%
Lenox Hill$1,425-52%
Sunnyside$1,400-7%
Neighborhood2 Beds Avg RentAnnual Change
Greenwich Village$9,425--
West Village$9,150-4%
NoMad$8,500-10%
Chelsea$8,246+11%
Brooklyn Heights$7,824-2%
Lincoln Square$7,665-3%
Upper West Side$7,359-9%
Tribeca$7,295--
Downtown Manhattan$7,237-7%
Midtown Manhattan$7,140+5%
Williamsburg$6,908+32%
Times Square$6,752-10%
Greenpoint$6,695--
Murray Hill$6,695-24%
Upper Manhattan$6,645-11%
Hudson Yards$6,593+5%
Hell's Kitchen$6,575+1%
Morningside Heights$6,570-18%
Northern Brooklyn$6,400+60%
Upper East Side$6,376+113%
Fort Greene$6,300--
Prospect Heights$6,110--
Yorkville$6,100+107%
Sutton Place$6,100--
Midtown East$6,033+32%
Gramercy Park$5,950+29%
Park Slope$5,900+23%
DUMBO$5,795--
Downtown Brooklyn$5,634-6%
Lenox Hill$4,750--
Alphabet City$4,750-51%
Financial District$4,600-40%
East Village$4,250-56%
Kips Bay$3,990-48%
Lower East Side$3,750--
Flatbush$3,450+19%
Harlem$3,400-52%
Bushwick$3,300+22%
East Harlem$3,200-7%
Northeastern Queens$2,800+10%
West Bronx$2,795+24%
Southeastern Queens$2,650+5%
Sunset Park$2,500+14%
Washington Heights$2,395+14%
Ridgewood$2,100-16%

Transportation

Commute Time

0-15 Mins

9%

15-30 Mins

15%

30-40 Mins

13%

40-60 Mins

18%

60+ Mins

45%

Transportation Scores

Percentage: 7878

Walk Score®

Has Sidewalks

Yes

Say 2 of 2 renters

Percentage: 6767

Bike Score®

Bike Friendly

Yes

Say 1 of 2 renters

Percentage: 7575

Transit Score®

They Are Located Near Public Transportation

Yes

Say 1 of 2 renters

Area Amenities

Top Score

Restaurants

4/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Cooking skills not required in Coney Island New York.

  1. Few restaurants per resident
  2. 91% more restaurants than average
  3. 29% more restaurants than areas of a similar size

Nightlife

4/5 stars based on undefined reviews

You've got a good shot at a great night out in Coney Island New York.

  1. Few bars and clubs per resident
  2. 66% more bars and clubs than average
  3. Far fewer bars and clubs than areas of a similar size

Medical Care

4/5 stars based on undefined reviews

This place is no sight for sore eyes. Plenty of docs in Coney Island New York.

  1. Few medical facilities per resident
  2. 95% more medical facilities than average
  3. 52% more medical facilities than areas of a similar size

Coffee

3.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Oh la latte, not a bad spot for getting a cup of joe.

  1. Few coffee shops per resident
  2. 61% more coffee shops than average
  3. Far fewer coffee shops than areas of a similar size

Theaters

3.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Coney Island New York is shaping up to be a big star in the theater scene.

  1. Few theaters per resident
  2. An average number of theaters
  3. A standard number of theaters compared to areas of a similar size

Fine Arts

3.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Coney Island New York draws a crowd for its fine art.

  1. Few fine art centers per resident
  2. 94% more fine art centers than average
  3. 62% more fine art centers than areas of a similar size

Gas Stations

3/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Bumper sticker city. This place is good for filling up.

  1. Few gas stations per resident
  2. 85% more gas stations than average
  3. 18% fewer gas stations than areas of a similar size

Grocery Stores

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Not bad on the supermarket score. Coney Island New York gets an average rating.

  1. Few grocery stores per resident
  2. An average number of grocery stores
  3. A standard number of grocery stores compared to areas of a similar size

Childcare

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Coney Island New York is taking baby steps toward having ample childcare options.

  1. Few daycares per resident
  2. 90% more daycares than average
  3. 28% more daycares than areas of a similar size

Retail Shops

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

The shopping scene here is a size medium.

  1. Few shops per resident
  2. 94% more shops than average
  3. 51% more shops than areas of a similar size

Amusement Parks

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Not exactly a Tilt-a-Whirl, but there's fun to be had.

  1. A high number of amusement parks per resident
  2. 95% more amusement parks than average
  3. 80% more amusement parks than areas of a similar size

Hospitals

2.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Coney Island New York gets the all clear for hospitals.

  1. Few hospitals per resident
  2. An average number of hospitals
  3. A standard number of hospitals compared to areas of a similar size

Parks

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Not too many park perks in Coney Island New York.

  1. Few parks per resident
  2. 90% more parks than average
  3. 37% more parks than areas of a similar size

Health and Fitness

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

You'll have to workout somewhere else to keep fit.

  1. Few gyms per resident
  2. 83% more gyms than average
  3. 87% fewer gyms than areas of a similar size

Pet Services

2/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Coney Island New York could do with more oppawtunities for pets.

  1. Few pet facilities per resident
  2. 52% more pet facilities than average
  3. Far fewer pet facilities than areas of a similar size

Schools

Percentage: 4/54/5

School Score

How satisfied do renters feel with the schools in this area.

Top Schools in Coney Island New York

Information provided by GreatSchools. To verify school enrollment eligibility, contact the school district directly.

Find Apartments in Nearby Cities

City1 Bed Price2 Beds Price
New York, NY 10 miles$5,097$6,992
Brooklyn, NY 6.1 miles$4,456$6,169
Manhattan, NY 12.5 miles------
Jersey City, NJ 11.5 miles$3,792$4,862
Astoria, NY 13.8 miles------
Chinatown, NY 9.7 miles------
Prince, NY 10.3 miles------
Knickerbocker, NY 9.6 miles------
Queens, NY 12.9 miles$2,400$2,800
Canal Street, NY 10 miles------

Find Apartments in Nearby Neighborhoods

Neighborhood1 Bed Price2 Beds Price
Brighton Beach 1.3 miles$1,650$2,550
Southern Brooklyn 1.4 miles$2,395$1,800
Gravesend 1.3 miles---$2,200
South Marlboro 1.3 miles---$2,200
Sea Gate 1.1 miles---$2,200