City Island Neighborhood Guide New York, NY
About
City Island is a picturesque and unique neighborhood located in the northeastern Bronx borough of New York City. It's a small, quaint community that's surrounded by the Long Island Sound and Eastchester Bay, giving it a distinct maritime charm. The island is primarily accessible via City Island Avenue, the neighborhood's main road, and is famous for its seafood restaurants, sailing opportunities, and the historic City Island Nautical Museum.
What You Will Love About City Island, New York, New York
- The relaxing, nautical ambiance of the neighborhood with its seafood restaurants, yacht clubs, and marinas offer an escape from the bustling city life.
- The neighborhood's rich history that's preserved and displayed at the City Island Nautical Museum.
- Its small-town feel, despite being part of the busy Bronx borough, is unmatched.
What's Nearby
City Island is near to Pelham Bay Park, the largest park in New York City, offering a wide range of outdoor activities such as golfing, bird watching, and hiking. Just a short drive away is Orchard Beach, a popular summer spot for both locals and tourists.
Lifestyle
The lifestyle on City Island is notably laid-back and closely connected to the sea. The community is tight-knit with many local events and gatherings based around boating, fishing, and enjoying locally sourced seafood.
Notice an Inaccuracy? Let Us Know.
See best properties in this area
Explore the Neighborhood
There are 46 restaurants, 5 grocery stores, and 4 parks within a mile of the City Island neighborhood.
New Way MarketRetail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•307 City Island Ave
- CTown Supermarkets
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.2 miles
385 City Island Ave
- IGA City Island
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.2 miles
385 City Island Ave
- New Way Market
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•307 City Island Ave
- City Island Liquors
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Liquor Store
•0.1 miles
358 City Island Ave
- Jgl Wines & Liquors
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Liquor Store
•0.1 miles
358 City Island Ave
- CTown Supermarkets
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.2 miles
385 City Island Ave
- IGA City Island
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.2 miles
385 City Island Ave
Lickety SplitDining and Drinking, Dessert Shop, Ice Cream Parlor
•295 City Island Ave
- The Snug
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Restaurant, American Restaurant, Steakhouse
•302 City Island Ave
- City Island Diner
Dining and Drinking, Restaurant, Diner, American Restaurant, Sandwich Spot
•304 City Island Ave
- Pizza Place
Dining and Drinking, Restaurant, Pizzeria
•286 City Island Ave
- Paddys On the Island
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Restaurant, American Restaurant
•288 City Island Ave
- City Island Yogurt
Dining and Drinking, Dessert Shop, Frozen Yogurt Shop, Ice Cream Parlor
•313 City Island Ave
City Island PharmacyRetail, Drugstore
•290 City Island Ave
- Doggie Island
Business and Professional Services, Pet Service, Pet Grooming Service, Retail, Pet Supplies Store
•0.1 miles
268 City Island Ave
- Buddy's Hardware & Marine
Retail, Hardware Store
•0.1 miles
260 City Island Ave
- Jill's Cottage - Plant Parentage
Retail, Garden Center
•0.3 miles
152 City Island Ave
Hawkins ParkLandmarks and Outdoors, Park
•281 City Island Ave
- Clason Point Park
Landmarks and Outdoors, Park
•0.7 miles
1 City Island Ave
- Pelham Bay Park
Landmarks and Outdoors, Park, Playground
•1.1 miles
Watt Avenue
- Orchard Beach Handball Courts
Landmarks and Outdoors
•1.6 miles
2 Orchard Beach Rd
Focal Point GalleryArts and Entertainment, Art Gallery
•0.1 miles
321 City Island Ave
- Starving Artist Studio & Gallery Dbe
Arts and Entertainment, Performing Arts Venue, Concert Hall, Music Venue, Dining and Drinking, Cafe, Coffee, and Tea House, Café
•0.1 miles
249 City Island Ave
- City Island Nautical Museum
Arts and Entertainment, Museum
•0.1 miles
190 Fordham St
- One World Arts
Arts and Entertainment, Performing Arts Venue, Music Venue
•0.2 miles
103 Centre St
- City Island Theater Group
Arts and Entertainment, Performing Arts Venue, Music Venue, Theater
•0.4 miles
116 City Island Ave
- Ajkun Ballet Theatre
Arts and Entertainment, Performing Arts Venue, Music Venue, Theater
•0.5 miles
193 Cross St
City Island LaundromatBusiness and Professional Services, Laundromat
•310 City Island Ave
- Scalp Tats NYC
Business and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service
•280 City Island Ave
- Eden Beauty Bar
Business and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service, Hair Salon
•310 City Island Ave
- City Island Tattoos
Business and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service, Tattoo Parlor
•314 City Island Ave
- Eden Beauty Studio
Business and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service
•312 City Island Ave
- New Bay Rose Nail Spa
Business and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service, Nail Salon
•329 City Island Ave
Ultra Sports CenterRetail, Sporting Goods Retail, Fishing Store
•0.1 miles
225 Fordham Pl
- Dragon Path Academy
Sports and Recreation, Martial Arts Dojo
•0.2 miles
229 City Island Ave
Barron's Marine SvcesSports and Recreation, Recreation Center
•0.2 miles
350 Fordham Pl
- Doyle Ploch Sailmakers
Retail, Sporting Goods Retail
•0.2 miles
225 Fordham St
- Harlem Yacht Club
Sports and Recreation, Sports Club
•0.3 miles
417 Hunter Ave
- Touring Kayak Club Ny
Sports and Recreation, Sports Club
•0.4 miles
205 Beach St
The SnugDining and Drinking, Bar, Restaurant, American Restaurant, Steakhouse
•302 City Island Ave
- Paddys On the Island
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Restaurant, American Restaurant
•288 City Island Ave
- Alehouse City Island
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Pub, Restaurant
•288 City Island Ave
- Man Overboard
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Dive Bar, Restaurant
•0.1 miles
247 City Island Ave
- Caliente’s
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Cocktail Bar, Restaurant, Seafood Restaurant
•0.2 miles
414 City Island Ave
- Fella's
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Restaurant, American Restaurant
•0.4 miles
522 City Island Ave
City Island Library - New York Public LibraryCommunity and Government, Library
•0.1 miles
320 City Island Ave
- City Island Community Center
Community and Government, Community Center
•0.1 miles
190 Fordham St
City Island Apartments and Rentals
33 Rental properties in City Island, New York, NY.
Cost of Living
| Category | Compare to State Avg. | Compare to National Avg. |
|---|---|---|
| housing | 10.1% | 67.6% |
| utilities | 0.1% | 33.7% |
| food | 0.9% | 5.3% |
| transportation | 1.1% | 6.4% |
| healthcare | 0.7% | 11% |
City Island Demographics
City Island Transportation
Car-Dependent
Somewhat Bikeable
City Island Schools
- 5/10
Grades K-8 • Public
- 4/10
Grades 6-8 • Public
- 8/10
Urban Institute Of Mathematics
Grades 6-8 • Public
- NRNo Rating
St Mary Star Of The Sea School
Grades PK, K-8 • Private
- NRNo Rating
Grades PK-8 • Private
- 5/10
Grades 6-12 • Charter
- 6/10
Bronx Charter School For Better Learning Ii
Grades K-5 • Charter
Neighborhoods Around City Island
| Neighborhood | StudioAvg Rent | Annual Change |
|---|---|---|
| East BronxNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $1,517 | 0% |
| DowntownNeighborhood in Bronx, New-york | $1,517 | 0% |
| Pelham ParkwayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| ParkchesterNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $1,517 | 0% |
| Downtown New RochelleNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | $2,195 | 5% |
| Morris ParkNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Co-op CityNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| South SideNeighborhood in Mount-vernon, New-york | -- | -- |
| Pelham BayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| AllertonNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Throgs NeckNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| WakefieldNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| OlinvilleNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Clason PointNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Country ClubNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| WilliamsbridgeNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Bay TerraceNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Bronx RiverNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| South SideNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| Pelham GardensNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Paul EstateNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| EdenwaldNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| BronxwoodNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Van NestNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| UnionportNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| BaychesterNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Stratton ParkNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| ManorhavenNeighborhood in Manorhaven, New-york | -- | -- |
| Homewood ParkNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| West EndNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| Westchester SquareNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| SoundviewNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Mount Vernon HeightsNeighborhood in Mount-vernon, New-york | -- | -- |
| Saddle RockNeighborhood in Great-neck, New-york | -- | -- |
| Castle HillNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| East EndNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| Soundview-BrucknerNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Neighborhood | 1 BedAvg Rent | Annual Change |
|---|---|---|
| East BronxNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $1,767 | 32% |
| DowntownNeighborhood in Bronx, New-york | $1,767 | 32% |
| Pelham ParkwayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $2,599 | -- |
| ParkchesterNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $1,767 | 0% |
| Downtown New RochelleNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | $3,215 | 11% |
| Morris ParkNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Co-op CityNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| South SideNeighborhood in Mount-vernon, New-york | $2,099 | 180% |
| Pelham BayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| AllertonNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Throgs NeckNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| WakefieldNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| OlinvilleNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Clason PointNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Country ClubNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| WilliamsbridgeNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Bay TerraceNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Bronx RiverNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| South SideNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | $2,095 | -- |
| Pelham GardensNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Paul EstateNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| EdenwaldNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| BronxwoodNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Van NestNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| UnionportNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| BaychesterNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Stratton ParkNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| ManorhavenNeighborhood in Manorhaven, New-york | -- | -- |
| Homewood ParkNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| West EndNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| Westchester SquareNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| SoundviewNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Mount Vernon HeightsNeighborhood in Mount-vernon, New-york | -- | -- |
| Saddle RockNeighborhood in Great-neck, New-york | -- | -- |
| Castle HillNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| East EndNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | $2,095 | -- |
| Soundview-BrucknerNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Neighborhood | 2 BedsAvg Rent | Annual Change |
|---|---|---|
| East BronxNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $2,017 | 28% |
| DowntownNeighborhood in Bronx, New-york | $2,017 | 16% |
| Pelham ParkwayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $2,849 | 2% |
| ParkchesterNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $2,017 | 0% |
| Downtown New RochelleNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | $3,973 | 10% |
| Morris ParkNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Co-op CityNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| South SideNeighborhood in Mount-vernon, New-york | $2,399 | 13% |
| Pelham BayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| AllertonNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Throgs NeckNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| WakefieldNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| OlinvilleNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Clason PointNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Country ClubNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| WilliamsbridgeNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Bay TerraceNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $2,500 | -- |
| Bronx RiverNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| South SideNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| Pelham GardensNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Paul EstateNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| EdenwaldNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| BronxwoodNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Van NestNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| UnionportNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| BaychesterNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Stratton ParkNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| ManorhavenNeighborhood in Manorhaven, New-york | $3,500 | -- |
| Homewood ParkNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| West EndNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| Westchester SquareNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| SoundviewNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Mount Vernon HeightsNeighborhood in Mount-vernon, New-york | -- | -- |
| Saddle RockNeighborhood in Great-neck, New-york | -- | -- |
| Castle HillNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| East EndNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| Soundview-BrucknerNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Neighborhood | 3 BedsAvg Rent | Annual Change |
|---|---|---|
| East BronxNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $3,000 | 0% |
| DowntownNeighborhood in Bronx, New-york | $3,000 | 0% |
| Pelham ParkwayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| ParkchesterNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $3,000 | 0% |
| Downtown New RochelleNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | $5,862 | 8% |
| Morris ParkNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Co-op CityNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| South SideNeighborhood in Mount-vernon, New-york | $3,200 | 7% |
| Pelham BayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| AllertonNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Throgs NeckNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| WakefieldNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $3,606 | -- |
| OlinvilleNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Clason PointNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Country ClubNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| WilliamsbridgeNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Bay TerraceNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $3,500 | -- |
| Bronx RiverNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| South SideNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| Pelham GardensNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Paul EstateNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| EdenwaldNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| BronxwoodNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Van NestNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| UnionportNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| BaychesterNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Stratton ParkNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| ManorhavenNeighborhood in Manorhaven, New-york | $4,200 | -- |
| Homewood ParkNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| West EndNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| Westchester SquareNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| SoundviewNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Mount Vernon HeightsNeighborhood in Mount-vernon, New-york | -- | -- |
| Saddle RockNeighborhood in Great-neck, New-york | -- | -- |
| Castle HillNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| East EndNeighborhood in New-rochelle, New-york | -- | -- |
| Soundview-BrucknerNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |