Tottenville Neighborhood Guide New York, NY
About
Tottenville is a quaint, historic neighborhood located on the South Shore of Staten Island, New York. Known for its small-town charm, it's rich in maritime history and contains the highest concentration of old houses in Staten Island, including several listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The area is bounded by the Arthur Kill waterway and its prominent landmarks include the Conference House and Biddle House. Key roads include Amboy Road, Main Street, and Arthur Kill Road.
What You Will Love About Tottenville, New York, New York
- You'll love Tottenville's peaceful, suburban feel while still being part of bustling New York City.
- The neighborhood's rich history and preserved Victorian architecture provide a unique charm.
- Tottenville boasts beautiful waterfront views and walking paths along the Arthur Kill.
- This community-centric neighborhood offers numerous dining and shopping options on Main Street.
What’s Nearby
Tottenville is near the southernmost point of New York State at the Conference House Park, a historic site where peace talks to end the Revolutionary War were held. It's also close to the Outerbridge Crossing, providing convenient access to New Jersey. Other notable nearby attractions include the South Shore Golf Course and Clay Pit Ponds State Park Preserve.
Lifestyle
The lifestyle in Tottenville is relaxed and community-oriented, with a mix of families, retirees, and young professionals. The neighborhood often hosts local events and festivals, encouraging a strong sense of community. Outdoor activities are popular due to the nearby parks and waterfront.
Notice an Inaccuracy? Let Us Know.
See best properties in this area
Explore the Neighborhood
There are 184 restaurants, 33 grocery stores, and 9 parks within a mile of the Tottenville neighborhood.
A Food MartRetail, Food and Beverage Retail, Gourmet Store, Grocery Store
•0.2 miles
7254 Amboy Rd
- Tottenville Food Mart
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.2 miles
7254 Amboy Rd
- Top Tomato Super Store
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.3 miles
240 Page Ave
- El Rancho Deli & Grocery
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Gourmet Store, Grocery Store
•0.5 miles
167 Main St
- Simple Foods of Staten Island
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.6 miles
87 Ellis St
- La Bella Marketplace
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.6 miles
99 Ellis St
- A Food Mart
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Gourmet Store, Grocery Store
•0.2 miles
7254 Amboy Rd
- Tottenville Food Mart
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.2 miles
7254 Amboy Rd
- John's Deli
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Gourmet Store
•0.3 miles
7423 Amboy Rd
- Top Tomato Super Store
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.3 miles
240 Page Ave
- El Rancho Deli & Grocery
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Gourmet Store, Grocery Store
•0.5 miles
167 Main St
- Simple Foods of Staten Island
Retail, Food and Beverage Retail, Grocery Store
•0.6 miles
87 Ellis St
Deluca's Italian RestaurantDining and Drinking, Restaurant, Pizzeria, Italian Restaurant
•0.2 miles
7324 Amboy Rd
- Da Nico of Mulberry Street
Dining and Drinking, Restaurant, Italian Restaurant
•0.2 miles
7324 Amboy Rd
- Rocky Toto's Original Italian Restaurant
Dining and Drinking, Restaurant, Italian Restaurant
•0.2 miles
7324 Amboy Rd
- South Shore Deli
Dining and Drinking, Restaurant, Deli
•0.2 miles
7344 Amboy Rd
- Belli Baci Bakery
Dining and Drinking, Bakery, Restaurant
•0.2 miles
7358 Amboy Rd
- Dani's Italian Bistro
Dining and Drinking, Restaurant, Bistro, Italian Restaurant
•0.2 miles
7331 Amboy Rd
Ninetynine Cents & MoreRetail, Discount Store
•0.2 miles
7323 Amboy Rd
- M & G Landscaping
Retail, Garden Center
•0.2 miles
7382 Amboy Rd
- Piccolo Puppies
Business and Professional Services, Pet Service, Pet Grooming Service, Retail, Pet Supplies Store
•0.5 miles
163 Main St
- Light N Lively Poodles
Business and Professional Services, Pet Service, Pet Grooming Service, Retail, Pet Supplies Store
•0.5 miles
7635 Amboy Rd
- Pawsitively Yours Dog Training
Business and Professional Services, Pet Service, Retail, Pet Supplies Store
•0.6 miles
71 Surfside Plz
- Walgreens
Retail, Drugstore
•0.6 miles
7001 Amboy Rd
Staten Island Companion Dog Training ClubLandmarks and Outdoors, Park, Dog Park
•0.6 miles
75 Ellis St
- Tottenville Shore Park
Landmarks and Outdoors, Park
•0.7 miles
Hopping Avenue, Tottenville
- Conference House Park
Landmarks and Outdoors, Park
•0.8 miles
7455 Hylan Blvd
- Richmond County Day Camp
Landmarks and Outdoors, Campground
•0.9 miles
6581 Hylan Blvd
- Mt. Loretto Unique Area
Landmarks and Outdoors, Park
•1.1 miles
6450 Hylan Blvd
- Mount Loretto Unique Area
Landmarks and Outdoors, Park, Travel and Transportation
•1.2 miles
6450 Hylan Blvd
Dream Studios For The Performing ArtsArts and Entertainment, Performing Arts Venue, Music Venue
•0.2 miles
7315 Amboy Rd
- Cape House Gallery
Arts and Entertainment, Art Gallery
•0.3 miles
7440 Amboy Rd
- Aloysia's Lounge
Arts and Entertainment, Pool Hall, Dining and Drinking, Bar, Cocktail Bar, Lounge
•0.4 miles
7095 Amboy Rd
- Colors of Fun
Arts and Entertainment
•0.5 miles
153 Main St
- Party Jam
Arts and Entertainment
•0.6 miles
75 Ellis St
- E Squared Cafe
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Hookah Bar, Arts and Entertainment
•0.7 miles
240 Page Ave
Episode NailsBusiness and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service, Nail Salon
•0.2 miles
7325 Amboy Rd
- Act 1 Barber Shop
Business and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service, Barbershop
•0.2 miles
7333 Amboy Rd
- Precision Cuts
Business and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service, Hair Salon
•0.2 miles
7305 Amboy Rd
- Suave Barbershop
Business and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service, Barbershop
•0.2 miles
7305 Amboy Rd
- Mia Passione Salon
Business and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service, Hair Salon
•0.2 miles
7321 Amboy Rd
- Viva
Business and Professional Services, Health and Beauty Service, Nail Salon
•0.2 miles
7335 Amboy Rd
Tottenville Racquet ClubSports and Recreation, Racquet Sports, Tennis, Tennis Court
•0.1 miles
36 Sprague Ave
- Tottenville Swimming Pool
Sports and Recreation, Water Sports, Swimming, Swimming Pool
•0.3 miles
6960 Hylan Blvd
- South Shore Little League
Sports and Recreation, Baseball, Baseball Club
•0.3 miles
243 Bedell Ave
- Mike's Bike Shop
Retail, Sporting Goods Retail, Bicycle Store
•0.4 miles
7522 Amboy Rd
Gigante Dance CenterSports and Recreation, Gym and Studio, Dance Studio
•0.5 miles
153 Main St
- New York Dojo Institute
Sports and Recreation, Martial Arts Dojo
•0.5 miles
160 Main St
Taqueria Restaurant Tres AmigosDining and Drinking, Bar, Restaurant, Mexican Restaurant, Spanish Restaurant
•0.4 miles
7528 Amboy Rd
- B & E's Neighborhood Pub
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Pub, Sports Bar, Restaurant, BBQ Joint
•0.4 miles
225 Main St
- Aloysia's Lounge
Arts and Entertainment, Pool Hall, Dining and Drinking, Bar, Cocktail Bar, Lounge
•0.4 miles
7095 Amboy Rd
- W's Bar and Restaurant
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Sports Bar, Restaurant
•0.6 miles
7001 Amboy Rd
- W's
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Sports Bar, Restaurant, Burger Joint, American Restaurant
•0.6 miles
7001 Amboy Rd
- Mister E's
Dining and Drinking, Bar, Restaurant
•0.6 miles
20 Ellis St
New York Public Library - TottenvilleCommunity and Government, Library
•0.2 miles
7430 Amboy Rd
- Staten Island Mental Health Society
Business and Professional Services, Child Care Service, Community and Government, Education, Preschool
•0.3 miles
100 Brighton St
- Eye Level Learning Center
Community and Government, Education, Preschool
•1.1 miles
4852 Arthur Kill Rd
- Gateway Academy
Community and Government, Education, Preschool
•1.1 miles
200 Boscombe Ave
- Cyomiv Community Center
Community and Government, Community Center
•1.2 miles
6541 Hylan Blvd
- Perth Amboy Public Schools
Business and Professional Services, Child Care Service, Community and Government, Education, Preschool
•1.4 miles
351 Mechanic St
Tottenville Medical PavillionHealth and Medicine, Hospital
•0.4 miles
7098 Amboy Rd
- ProHEALTH Circle Urgent Care of Tottenville
Health and Medicine, Urgent Care Center
•0.6 miles
7001 Amboy Rd
- NYPD - 123rd Precinct
Community and Government, Government Building, Law Enforcement and Public Safety, Police Station
•0.6 miles
116 Main St
- BellaVita CBD & Wellness
Health and Medicine, Hospital
•1.0 mile
4885 Arthur Kill Rd
Tottenville Apartments and Rentals
33 Rental properties in Tottenville, New York, NY.
Cost of Living
| Category | Compare to State Avg. | Compare to National Avg. |
|---|---|---|
| housing | 9.9% | 68.4% |
| utilities | 0.1% | 31.7% |
| food | 1.1% | 5.3% |
| transportation | 0.7% | 5% |
| healthcare | 0.4% | 10.5% |
Tottenville Demographics
Tottenville Reviews
Noise Late At Night
No
Say 2 of 2 renters
Area Has Litter
No
Say 2 of 2 renters
Mostly Older Buildings
No
Say 2 of 2 renters
Nearby Parks
Yes
Say 2 of 2 renters
Near Schools
Yes
Say 2 of 2 renters
Pet Friendly
Yes
Say 2 of 2 renters
Tottenville Transportation
Car-Dependent
Somewhat Bikeable
Good Transit
The C Train
Train Stop
168TH St
Tottenville
Train Stop
Arthur Kill Rd
MTA SIR - Tottenville
Train Stop
Arthur Kill Rd
Source: foursquare.com
Nelvi Transit
Bus Stop
440 State St
MTA Charleston Bus Depot
Bus Stop
4700 Arthur Kill Rd
Source: foursquare.com
The C Train
Train Stop
168TH St
Tottenville
Train Stop
Arthur Kill Rd
MTA SIR - Tottenville
Train Stop
Arthur Kill Rd
Source: foursquare.com
Tottenville Schools
- 10/10
Grades 6-8 • Public
- 8/10
Grades PK, K-5 • Public
- 7/10
P.S. 6 Corporal Allan F. Kivlehan School
Grades PK, K-5 • Public
- NRNo Rating
Grades PK-8 • Private
- NRNo Rating
Staten Island Montessori School
Grades PK, K-8 • Private
- 2/10
Academy For Urban Leadership Cs
Grades 7-12 • Charter
- 2/10
Lois And Richard Early College Charter School
Grades 8-11 • Charter
Neighborhoods Around Tottenville
| Neighborhood | StudioAvg Rent | Annual Change |
|---|---|---|
| HarbortownNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| The WaterfrontNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $1,535 | 6% |
| South ShoreNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $1,000 | 17% |
| Downtown Perth AmboyNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| HopelawnNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Southwestern Perth AmboyNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Hall AvenueNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| EltingvilleNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Spa SpringsNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Prince's BayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Laurence HarborNeighborhood in Laurence-harbor, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| WoodrowNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $1,300 | -- |
| MaurerNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| GreenridgeNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Amboy AvenueNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Arden HeightsNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Western Section of the WaterfrontNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Cliffwood BeachNeighborhood in Cliffwood-beach, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Neighborhood | 1 BedAvg Rent | Annual Change |
|---|---|---|
| HarbortownNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| The WaterfrontNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $1,815 | 6% |
| South ShoreNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $1,600 | 7% |
| Downtown Perth AmboyNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| HopelawnNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Southwestern Perth AmboyNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $1,954 | -- |
| Hall AvenueNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $1,600 | -- |
| EltingvilleNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $1,700 | 17% |
| Spa SpringsNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $1,845 | -- |
| Prince's BayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $1,600 | -- |
| Laurence HarborNeighborhood in Laurence-harbor, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| WoodrowNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $1,600 | 0% |
| MaurerNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| GreenridgeNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Amboy AvenueNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $1,850 | -- |
| Arden HeightsNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Western Section of the WaterfrontNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Cliffwood BeachNeighborhood in Cliffwood-beach, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Neighborhood | 2 BedsAvg Rent | Annual Change |
|---|---|---|
| HarbortownNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,675 | 13% |
| The WaterfrontNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,295 | 10% |
| South ShoreNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $2,100 | 14% |
| Downtown Perth AmboyNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| HopelawnNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Southwestern Perth AmboyNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,577 | -- |
| Hall AvenueNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,250 | 0% |
| EltingvilleNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Spa SpringsNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,165 | -- |
| Prince's BayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Laurence HarborNeighborhood in Laurence-harbor, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| WoodrowNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| MaurerNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| GreenridgeNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Amboy AvenueNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,100 | 14% |
| Arden HeightsNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Western Section of the WaterfrontNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Cliffwood BeachNeighborhood in Cliffwood-beach, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Neighborhood | 3 BedsAvg Rent | Annual Change |
|---|---|---|
| HarbortownNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $3,340 | 16% |
| The WaterfrontNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,205 | 5% |
| South ShoreNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $3,000 | 11% |
| Downtown Perth AmboyNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,900 | -- |
| HopelawnNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $3,100 | -- |
| Southwestern Perth AmboyNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $3,333 | -- |
| Hall AvenueNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,500 | -- |
| EltingvilleNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Spa SpringsNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Prince's BayNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Laurence HarborNeighborhood in Laurence-harbor, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| WoodrowNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | $3,000 | -- |
| MaurerNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,600 | -- |
| GreenridgeNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Amboy AvenueNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | $2,550 | -- |
| Arden HeightsNeighborhood in New-york, New-york | -- | -- |
| Western Section of the WaterfrontNeighborhood in Perth-amboy, New-jersey | -- | -- |
| Cliffwood BeachNeighborhood in Cliffwood-beach, New-jersey | -- | -- |