Saved Properties
Search
Moving Center
List a Property
Blog
Sign In
Home
…
New York
Shelter Island
Houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY
Max Price
Beds
More filters
Houses
X
Clear All
Not finding what you’re looking for?
Add Apartments
297 Properties
Sort by:
Best Match
1
/
16
$3,500
HOME FOR RENT
12 Bay View Ave
East Hampton, NY 11937
4 Beds • 4 Bath
The Hamptons
Contact Property
(901) 399-9077
1
/
19
$20,000
HOME FOR RENT
42 Manor Ln
East Hampton, NY 11937
4 Beds • 2 Bath
The Hamptons
Contact Property
(646) 432-9438
1
/
15
$3,500
HOME FOR RENT
25 Fords Ln
Southampton, NY 11968
3 Beds • 2 Bath
The Hamptons
Contact Property
(901) 399-9077
But wait, there's more!
Add apartments to view more properties.
See more options
1
/
53
$1,465+
(2)
NSB New London Homes
100 Tern Road
Groton, CT 06340
2–4 Beds • 1–2 Baths
Contact Property
(860) 237-5921
1
/
14
$3,500
HOME FOR RENT
6 Potato Field Ct
Southampton, NY 11968
3 Beds • 3 Bath
The Hamptons
Contact Property
(901) 399-9077
1
/
7
$1,900
HOME FOR RENT
7 Sunset Ln
Clinton, CT 06413
2 Beds • 1 Bath
Contact Property
(203) 444-1433
Filter by price
Set a maximum price for your search.
$500
$500
$5000
Apply
$1,500
HOME FOR RENT
2 Main St
Essex, CT 06426
2 Beds • 1 Bath
Contact Property
(203) 641-9384
3D
Tour
$912+
(10)
Nutmeg Woods
84 Hawthorne Dr North
New London, CT 06320
Studio–3 Beds • 1 Bath
10+ Units Available
Updated 1 day ago
Contact Property
(860) 333-6267
$2,100
HOME FOR RENT
23 Kelseytown Rd
Killingworth, CT 06419
4 Beds • 2 Bath
Contact Property
(203) 641-9384
Filter by bedrooms
How many bedrooms do you need?
Studio
1
2
3
Apply
$1,800
HOME FOR RENT
213 W Shore Ave
Groton, CT 06340
4 Beds • 2 Bath
Contact Property
(860) 331-1510
$1,300
HOME FOR RENT
89 Sound Breeze Ave
Groton, CT 06340
4 Beds • 2 Bath
Contact Property
(860) 331-1510
$915+
Courtview Square Apartments
309 Crystal Ave
New London, CT 06320
1 Bed • 1 Bath
2 Units Available
Contact Property
(860) 910-1409
Filter by bathrooms
How many bathrooms do you need?
1
2
3+
Apply
$1,400
HOME FOR RENT
8 Oak St
Groton, CT 06340
4 Beds • 2 Bath
Contact Property
(860) 331-1510
$1,600
HOME FOR RENT
3 Beach Rd
Groton, CT 06340
6 Beds • 2 Bath
Contact Property
(860) 331-1510
$2,000
HOME FOR RENT
10 Middlefield St
Groton, CT 06340
4 Beds • 2 Bath
Contact Property
(860) 331-1510
3D
Tour
$950
Phoenix Apartments
355 Long Hill Road
Groton, CT 06340
1 Bed • 1 Bath
Contact Property
(860) 865-1556
$1,190
HOME FOR RENT
31 W Main St
Groton, CT 06340
1 Bed • 1 Bath
Contact Property
(860) 536-8300
$1,550
HOME FOR RENT
97 Whalehead Rd
Ledyard, CT 06335
3 Beds • 2 Bath
Contact Property
(401) 371-9235
$12,000
HOME FOR RENT
130 6th St
Greenport, NY 11944
5 Beds • 2 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 477-5990
3D
Tour
$1,175+
60 Mansfield Road
New London, CT 06320
Studio–2 Beds • 1–2 Baths
Contact Property
(860) 451-5813
$11,000
HOME FOR RENT
307 4th St
Greenport, NY 11944
3 Beds • 2 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 765-3800
$29,000
HOME FOR RENT
219 6th St
Greenport, NY 11944
4 Beds • 1 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 477-2220
$20,000
HOME FOR RENT
515 4th St
Greenport, NY 11944
3 Beds • 2 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 734-7100
3D
Tour
$1,350+
Pleasant Valley
700 Pleasnt Valley Rd
Groton, CT 06340
Studio–2 Beds • 1–2 Baths
Updated 5 days ago
Contact Property
(860) 574-3313
$2,500
HOME FOR RENT
310 Front St
Greenport, NY 11944
2 Beds • 1 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 477-2220
$60,000
HOME FOR RENT
144 Bay Ave
Greenport, NY 11944
4 Beds • 3 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 734-0390
$3,000
HOME FOR RENT
317 South St
Greenport, NY 11944
4 Beds • 1 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 477-2730
$900+
The River View Apartments
26 Bishop Lane
Groton, CT 06340
1–2 Beds • 1 Bath
Contact Property
(860) 581-4119
$18,000
HOME FOR RENT
950 Blue Marlin Dr
Southold, NY 11971
4 Beds • 4 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 477-5990
$75,000
HOME FOR RENT
4565 Paradise Point Rd
Southold, NY 11971
4 Beds • 4 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 765-5333
$6,000
HOME FOR RENT
335 Osprey Nest Rd
Greenport, NY 11944
3 Beds • 2 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 477-2220
3D
Tour
$949+
(4)
Eagle Pointe
8 Michael Road Suite B
New London, CT 06320
1–3 Beds • 1 Bath
10+ Units Available
Updated 1 day ago
Contact Property
(860) 598-4870
$22,500
HOME FOR RENT
235 Bailey Ave
Greenport, NY 11944
2 Beds • 2 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 765-3800
$8,000
HOME FOR RENT
845 Budds Pond Rd
Southold, NY 11971
3 Beds • 2 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 765-5333
$45,000
HOME FOR RENT
870 Bay Home Rd
Southold, NY 11971
4 Beds • 2 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 252-5653
$995+
(1)
Long Meadow Landings
41 South Road
Groton, CT 06340
Loft–2 Beds • 1 Bath
2 Units Available
Contact Property
(860) 899-1971
$6,000
HOME FOR RENT
340 Westwood Ln
Greenport, NY 11944
3 Beds • 2 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 477-2220
$34,000
HOME FOR RENT
400 Green Hill Ln
Greenport, NY 11944
4 Beds • 2 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 765-3800
$20,000
HOME FOR RENT
400 Windjammer Dr
Southold, NY 11971
4 Beds • 4 Bath
Northfork
Contact Property
(631) 734-7100
1
-
30
of
297
Properties
Next Page >
Shelter Island House Options
2 Bedroom Houses
3 Bedroom Houses
Cheap Houses
Shelter Island Apartment Options
Pet Friendly Apartments
Furnished Apartments
Cheap Apartments
Search by Property Type
Shelter Island Apartments
Find Houses in Nearby Cities
Amagansett, NY
Cutchogue, NY
East Marion, NY
Fenwick, CT
Greenport, NY
Mattituck, NY
North Haven, NY
Old Saybrook, CT
Orient, NY
Peconic, NY
Riverhead, NY
Sag Harbor, NY
Saybrook Manor, CT
Shinnecock Hills, NY
Southold, NY
Westbrook, CT
Read More +
Find Houses in Nearby Neighborhoods
Downtown Mystic
Jefferson
Mystic Seaport
Northfork
Poquonnock Bridge
South New London
Williams
Read More +
Find Houses Near Local Colleges
Albert School, CT
Connecticut College, CT
Lyme Academy College of Fine Arts, CT
Mitchell College, CT
Read More +
Find Houses Near Local Military Bases
Naval Submarine Base New London, CT
Read More +
Find Houses in Nearby Zip Codes
11964, NY
Read More +