- Home
- New York
- Shelter Island
Houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY
More filters
- Houses
Not finding what you’re looking for?
296 Properties
1 / 16
(901) 399-9077
1 / 19
(646) 432-9438
1 / 15
(901) 399-9077
But wait, there's more!
Add apartments to view more properties.
1 / 53
3D Tour
$912+
(10)
84 Hawthorne Dr North
New London, CT 06320
New London, CT 06320
Studio–3 Beds • 1 Bath
10 Units Available
Updated 1 day ago
(860) 333-6267
1 / 14
(901) 399-9077
1 / 7
(203) 444-1433
Filter by price
Set a maximum price for your search.
$500
$500
$5000(203) 641-9384
(860) 237-5921
(203) 641-9384
Filter by bedrooms
How many bedrooms do you need?
(860) 331-1510
(860) 331-1510
(860) 910-1409
Filter by bathrooms
How many bathrooms do you need?
(860) 331-1510
(860) 331-1510
(860) 331-1510
(860) 536-8300
(401) 371-9235
(631) 477-5990
(631) 765-3800
(631) 477-2220
(631) 734-7100
3D Tour
$1,425+
1 Maple Tree Lane
East Lyme, CT 06333
East Lyme, CT 06333
Studio–3 Beds • 1–2 Baths
10+ Units Available
Updated 12 hours ago
(860) 269-5978
(631) 477-2220
(631) 734-0390
(631) 477-2730
(860) 581-4119
(631) 477-5990
(631) 765-5333
(631) 477-2220
3D Tour
$1,350+
700 Pleasnt Valley Rd
Groton, CT 06340
Groton, CT 06340
Studio–2 Beds • 1–2 Baths
Updated 4 days ago
(860) 574-3313
(631) 765-3800
(631) 765-5333
(631) 252-5653
3D Tour
$949+
(4)
8 Michael Road Suite B
New London, CT 06320
New London, CT 06320
1–3 Beds • 1 Bath
10+ Units Available
Updated 22 hours ago
(860) 598-4870
(631) 477-2220
(631) 765-3800
(631) 734-7100
1 - 30 of 296 PropertiesNext Page >