1. Home

Whitefish Bay, WI Houses For Rent

Beds

385 Properties

Average Rent in Whitefish Bay, WI

Avg. RentAnnual Change
Whitefish Bay 2 Beds - $1,375-
Last updated 6/19/2024

Search by Property Type

Local Guide

See what Whitefish Bay, WI has to offer.

Local Reviews

Right off of a river and a great park. It's a good balance between where I like to socialize and where I work.

the people also there is side walks it is close to the lake. you are safe here to enjoy they need more resturents i would saw and not expe nsive ones

I like that I live close to grocery stores, drug stores, gas stations and some restaurants. Being an older neighborhood, the houses are very nice with nice lawns, trees, and flowers.

My school is very nearby. I can walk to it (around 5-10 min) and it is only a 2 minute walk. There are also grocery stores very nearby.

Our apartment is solide, and the neighborhood is quies. Public transportation is available. There are two drug stores and a grocery store within walking distance. Several restaurands and coffee shops are available.

The school districts are great from elementary school to high school. I love the sidewalks make it safe to walk around the neighborhood and to the restaurants that are in the neighborhood.

Demographics

Education

High School

10%

Associate's

17%

Bachelor's

42%

Master's

26%

Doctorate

6%

Family Size

2 people

39%

3 people

22%

4 people

28%

5 people

10%

6+ people

2%

Household Income

0-50k

19%

50-100k

22%

100-150k

20%

150-200k

14%

200k+

25%

Age

0-10

16%

10-20

17%

20-45

27%

45-65

27%

65+

14%

Affordability

Percentage: 3/53/5

Renters gave this area a 3 out of 5 for affordability

Last updated 6/19/2024

*The rent information included in this summary is based on a median calculation of multifamily rental property inventory on Apartment Guide and Rent.com over the past 12-months and is for illustrative purposes only. This information does not constitute a pricing guarantee or financial advice related to the rental market.

Rent Trends

Average rent in Whitefish Bay, WI

In Whitefish Bay, WI, as of 2024, the average rent for apartments ranges from $1,375 to $1,375. And for a 2-bedroom apartment, renters can expect to pay an average of $1,375.

Annual Rent Change Over the Past 12 Months

2 Beds

-

Changed from $1,375 to $1,375
Last updated 6/19/2024

Rent Ranges

Apartment PricesProportion
0%
0%
45%
9%
45%

Compare Other Cities

CityStudio Avg RentAnnual Change
Brookfield$1,589-19%
Oconomowoc$1,443-10%
Wauwatosa$1,439-34%
Pleasant Prairie$1,410+1%
Sheboygan$1,0500%
South Milwaukee$995--
Milwaukee$975-19%
West Allis$895+29%
West Bend$895+2%
Kenosha$875+35%
Oak Creek$875--
Greenfield$864--
Racine$800-29%
Waukesha$700-29%
City1 Bed Avg RentAnnual Change
Pleasant Prairie$1,650+4%
Oconomowoc$1,600-7%
Wauwatosa$1,540+81%
Brookfield$1,535+3%
New Berlin$1,504+22%
Oak Creek$1,496+5%
Greenfield$1,492+42%
Milwaukee$1,4650%
Waukesha$1,410+14%
Sheboygan$1,3500%
South Milwaukee$1,299+24%
West Bend$1,200+4%
Elkhorn$1,145--
Kenosha$1,070-3%
Zion$1,050+11%
West Allis$9950%
Racine$910+8%
Cudahy$9000%
Watertown$8800%
City2 Beds Avg RentAnnual Change
Wauwatosa$2,115--
Pleasant Prairie$2,095+2%
Lake Geneva$2,064+17%
Brookfield$2,052+7%
Sheboygan$1,8000%
Milwaukee$1,760+1%
Oak Creek$1,753+52%
West Bend$1,662+5%
Greenfield$1,625+44%
New Berlin$1,595+20%
Waukesha$1,461+5%
Kenosha$1,341-1%
South Milwaukee$1,299-7%
West Allis$1,295--
Cudahy$1,255+31%
Zion$1,250+14%
Elkhorn$1,250-2%
Antioch$1,212+10%
Racine$1,118+7%
Menomonee Falls$1,050--
Watertown$1,020+9%
Oconomowoc$960-50%

Transportation

Commute Time

0-15 Mins

25%

15-30 Mins

49%

30-40 Mins

15%

40-60 Mins

7%

60+ Mins

4%

Transportation Scores

Percentage: 6060

Walk Score®

Walkable

Yes

Say 7 of 11 renters

Has Sidewalks

Yes

Say 9 of 11 renters

Percentage: 6262

Bike Score®

Bike Friendly

Yes

Say 10 of 11 renters

Area Amenities

Top Score

Restaurants

1.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Better stock your pantry because the restaurant scene is paltry.

  1. Few restaurants per resident
  2. 97% fewer restaurants than average
  3. 42% fewer restaurants than areas of a similar size

Retail Shops

1.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

This place is great for recovering shopaholics - a low retail score.

  1. Few shops per resident
  2. 52% fewer shops than average
  3. Significantly more shops than areas of a similar size

Health and Fitness

1.5/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Do you even lift, bro? Whitefish Bay is weak on fitness.

  1. Few gyms per resident
  2. 75% fewer gyms than average
  3. Significantly more gyms than areas of a similar size

Grocery Stores

1/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Got a hunch you'll be dialing for lunch.

  1. Few grocery stores per resident
  2. 100% fewer grocery stores than average
  3. 100% fewer grocery stores than areas of a similar size

Coffee

1/5 stars based on undefined reviews

Not a latte coffee shops in Whitefish Bay.

  1. Few coffee shops per resident
  2. 100% fewer coffee shops than average
  3. 100% fewer coffee shops than areas of a similar size

Gas Stations

1/5 stars based on undefined reviews

The gas stations here are few and far between.

  1. Few gas stations per resident
  2. 100% fewer gas stations than average
  3. 100% fewer gas stations than areas of a similar size

Area Features

Noise Late At Night

No

Say 10 of 11 renters

Nearby Parks

Yes

Say 10 of 11 renters

Pet Friendly

Yes

Say 10 of 11 renters

Tree Lined Streets

Yes

Say 10 of 11 renters

Busy Streets

No

Say 9 of 11 renters

Area Has Litter

No

Say 9 of 11 renters

Near Grocery Stores

Yes

Say 9 of 11 renters

Near Schools

Yes

Say 9 of 11 renters

Area Has Potholes

No

Say 9 of 11 renters

Good Place To Raise A Family

Yes

Say 9 of 11 renters

Safe For Families

Yes

Say 9 of 11 renters

Area Has Kids Play Outside

Yes

Say 8 of 11 renters

Maintained Yards

Yes

Say 8 of 11 renters

Quiet Area

Yes

Say 7 of 11 renters

Well Lit

Yes

Say 7 of 11 renters

Mostly Older Buildings

No

Say 6 of 11 renters

Near Downtown

No

Say 6 of 11 renters

Near Highways

No

Say 6 of 11 renters

Nice Views

No

Say 9 of 11 renters

Mostly Newer Buildings

No

Say 10 of 11 renters

Schools

Percentage: 4/54/5

School Score

How satisfied do renters feel with the schools in this area.

Top Schools in Whitefish Bay

Information provided by GreatSchools. To verify school enrollment eligibility, contact the school district directly.

Find Houses in Nearby Cities

City1 Bed Price2 Beds Price
Milwaukee, WI 5.2 miles$1,465$1,760
Hubbard, WI 2 miles------
Shorewood, WI 1.8 miles---$1,407
Wauwatosa, WI 7 miles$1,540$2,115
West Allis, WI 8.6 miles$995$1,295
Fifth Ward Milwaukee, WI 6.4 miles------
Glendale, WI 2.4 miles$1,375$1,720
Racine, WI 27.4 miles$910$1,118
Brookfield, WI 11 miles$1,535$2,052
Menomonee Falls, WI 11.9 miles---$1,050